December 6, 2005
Elton Brand:
Early-season MVP candidate dominates the Heat (37 pts, 12 reb, 6 bl) and leads the Clippers to a huge 99-89 win over the Southeast division leaders.
The Lead Item
Two Words For You:

Is Duke overrated at No. 1?

Halfway through college basketball's non-conference schedule, there's enough data to scan the latest Top 25 and figure out who's underrated and who's overrated.

(Inertia from preseason rankings annoys me to no end. For solid data points, I give credit based on who teams have actually beaten this season.)

Villanova (Rank: 4). As far as I'm concerned, they have the biggest "prove-it" win of the season: Beating then-No. 5 Oklahoma on Saturday. And that's without injured star forward Curtis Sumpter. They should be No. 1, at least this week.

Washington (Rank: 12). It's as if everyone has forgotten about last year's team. The polls look foolish when UW sits one spot below Gonzaga, even though they just beat them head-to-head Sunday night. Freshman Jon Brockman (13.3 ppg, 7.9 rpg) is one of the top frosh in the country.

Bucknell (Rank: 27). It's like voters can't get over that the jerseys say "Bucknell." Except they have already won at Syracuse and at DePaul. And this is the same team that shocked Kansas last year in the first round of the NCAAs. Where's the respect?

(Speaking of giant-killing Bucknell and 1-wannabe Villanova, they play tonight on ESPN 360 in tonight's must-follow game.)

Houston (Rank: 35). Any other team from a "real" league who beats two Top 25 teams (LSU, Arizona) in the same week would be ranked. If they can't make it THIS week, when will they ever? Isn't this type of feel-good story what the ballot's 25th-place vote should be used for?

Duke (Rank: 1). Talk about a reputation ranking! Duke barely beat Memphis two weeks ago and then narrowly beat Indiana last week. Most glaring, they needed a 40-foot prayer at the buzzer on Sunday to beat lightly regarded VA Tech -- and that was at home! That's not how a No. 1 team should be winning.

I'm not saying that Duke isn't one of the Top 5 teams; I'm arguing they're not worthy of being ranked No. 1 right now. And keeping them there because of inertia -- not factoring how they won or how other possible No. 1 teams around them did -- is what erodes a ranking's credibility.

I'll follow my own rules, though: Given the weight I put on the quality of opponent a team beats, my vote for the No. 1 team next week will go to the winner of the huge Duke-Texas game on Saturday.

MNF: Seahawks Roll
For Seahawks skeptics wondering if Seattle can win in January-type weather in a hostile road environment of the defending conference champs, there are far fewer questions today.

In the swirling snow, Seattle humiliated the Eagles with Philly's worst home loss in more than 40 years -- and handed them not just the worst loss of Philly's run as an NFC big dog, but arguably the coup de grace of the short-lived "Eagles Era."

The suddenly stout Seahawks are streaking toward home-field advantage throughout the NFC playoffs; it's OK to buy into them now. Meanwhile, the Eagles are a mess; all eyes on that Westbrook ankle MRI result.

Stevie Wonder: Motown legend added to Detroit SBXL pregame
Saints: To play some of '06 in Superdome (Too optimistic?)
G. Washington: Tops rival Terps; best CBB team in DC area?
Rashard Lewis: Slapped with DUI charge from Sept arrest
Brian Westbrook: Not able to finish MNF (ankle); MRI today
Braylon Edwards: After 2 TD game, out for the season (ACL)
Burnett to Jays?
We've secretly replaced the Toronto management with the management of the free-spending Yankees. Let's see if their customers notice...

Give the Blue Jays credit: They are making the biggest splash (or at least spending the most cash) in the free-agent market this offseason. First closer BJ Ryan, now starter AJ Burnett, reportedly ready to sign.

Here's why other teams will laugh and say "Take him": The Jays are offering a guaranteed 5th year. That's a huuuge gamble for a pitcher (even a young one) with a history of injuries.

(But if he's healthy, the Jays' frontline four of Halladay, Chacin, Towers and Burnett will be the best starting pitching in the division. Are they the '06 version of the White Sox's Buehrle-Garland-Contreras-Garcia?)

More MLB Hot Stove
Clemens done? Won't commit to Houston until early next year, which leaves the team hanging as they try to decode whether they need to find an ace replacement.

Nomar to Yankees? What?! I think this is what agents, GMs and the media do to amuse themselves during the down time at these events.

Boston shopping Clement? Move to tweak Theo? One rumor sends him and Nixon to Philly for Abreu; the other is to Milwaukee for Overbay.

World Baseball Classic
This is going to be huge. Certainly bigger than the All-Star Game. (But not quite as big as a World Series.) Because with so many players included, there's something to intrigue every fan:

There's the passion of nationalism; there's the heat of rivalries; there's the chance to watch unlikely players team up; there's the roster analysis, which sets up like the greatest baseball barstool debate you've ever had; there's the "bracket"-style tournament format that fans can easily follow; and there's the very real chance that the mighty U.S. will be beaten by the Dominican Republic.

Here's the wildest dynamic to watch: Will A-Rod play for the U.S. or the D.R.? Playing with the U.S. will help his endorsements; playing with the D.R. will give him cred. (Of course, NOT playing for the U.S. is its own decision with serious negative p.r. consequences.)

(My only complaint about the WBC? It will have to compete with March Madness. MLB didn't have another option, but the competition for your attention will be fierce next March, to say the least.)

Coaches' CFB Poll
I've been calling for greater college football Top 25 ballot transparency since the Quickie started three years ago, and yesterday, it finally came:

The individual results of the final coaches' poll was released. In the most intriguing development, Texas coach Mack Brown voted USC No. 1 over his team.

Now, let's not give him TOO much credit: He could afford to be magnanimous once he knew his team was a lock for the national-title game.

But the real fun is in the rundown of... hmm: let's call them "anomalies":

*6 of the 7 first-place votes for Texas came from coaches with ties to UT, either through the Big 12, as coaching alums or in-state peers.

*The SMU coach had Oregon 15th; he can expect a visit from the angry Oregon P.R. Squad.

*And Steve Spurrier apparently doesn't buy the whole Notre Dame thing; he had them ranked 14th. Someone's bitter....

The transparency did its job, illustrating that, yes, the coaches' poll is scattered with regional and personal bias. Now, how about some accountability?

Brady is "Sportsman"
Tom Brady: Most Clutch QB Ever? Possibly. NFL's Poster Guy? Definitely. Just-Like-You Internet User? Uh, depends on your habits.

But "SI Sportsman of the Year?" Maybe I'm a little thrown because Brady earned it last winter, and more than 10 months have gone by since.

He's the QB of the NFL's greatest dynasty and worthy-ish, but shouldn't the award have gone to the real mastermind: Charlie Weis?

After all, Weis didn't just coach and scheme Brady into "Sportsman"-level status; he then did the same thing with Notre Dame QB Brady Quinn, while turning Notre Dame into a national power. In one year.

(Okay, if not Weis, then how about Bill Belichick? Maybe SI didn't find him enough of a hottie. We all can't date Bridget Moynihan.)

Last point: As far as athlete-only "Sportsmen" candidates go, is there any difference between Brady and, say, Matt Leinart? Could have gone either way, especially if you combine him with Reggie Bush into "Co-Sportsmen."

(See Big 5 for my ballot.)

AJ Pierzynski:
In a fitting role, love-to-hate White Sox C will act as a guest "manager" to pro wrestlers this week. Will he fake out the ref on a dropped chair?
Today on
Quickie: Live!
CBB Top 25
Page 2 Index
Quickie "Sportsman" of 2005
Charlie Weis
Tutored *both* Brady
Bill Belichick
Despite fall issues
Leinart and Bush
"Co-" a cop-out, I know
Tom Brady
Still not enthusiastically
Lance Armstrong
How can he not make Top 5?

If Tim Duncan is the standard for NBA PFs, young stud Dwight Howard is still learning: MVP TD spanked him, 26 pts (9-17 FG) to 13 (4-18 FG).

Kerry Collins era stalls in Oakland: Desperate Norv is mulling turning the QB reins over to Marques Tuiasosopo. (Hey, Green Bay: Take a lesson...)

Is there method to Dolphins coach Nick Saban's madness? He's keeping Frerotte as starting QB despite Rosenfels' heroics (272 yds, 2 TDs, 19 min.)

Ryan Fitzpatrick Watch: Acknowledging that it was the play-calling, not the QB's fault, the Rams will let the rookie start again next week.

More college hoops: Potentially overrated No. 6 B.C. can notch a quality win in NYC when they play No. 14 Michigan St at 9 tonight on ESPN.

I appreciate Clemens' interest in pitching for the US next spring in the WBC, but my bet is he throws no more than a symbolic inning or two.

Sponsored Links