Aaron Small, pitcher
Photograph By Anthony J Causi/Icon SMI
Rise: After pitching in parts of eight seasons, he went 10-0 with a 3.20 ERA for the Yankees in 2005.
Fall: He started just three more major league games and was out of baseball after the 2006 season, finishing his career with 25 wins and a 5.20 ERA.
The latest: He was last seen in 2012 at the Yankees' annual Old Timers' Day.