Wednesday, April 21, 2004
Updated: April 22, 10:37 AM ET
Bader Ginsburg orders argument from NFL
ESPN.com news services
Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg asked the NFL on Wednesday to provide her with written arguments in response to documents filed by attorneys for Maurice Clarett that ask for an emergency lifting of the legal stay which is currently keeping Clarett and Mike Williams out of this weekend's draft, ESPN's Sal Paolantonio reports.
Ginsburg has given the NFL until 9 a.m. ET Thursday to provide its written argument, Paolantonio reports. After that, Ginsburg can issue a ruling based on the written arguments from each side, or refer it to the whole court.
Either way, Ginsburg is expected to rule before the draft, which is Saturday and Sunday, on whether the stay issued by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals should be lifted, Paolantonio reports.
Clarett's attorney, Alan Milstein, filed the emergency appeal on Tuesday. A day earlier, the federal appeals court issued the stay, putting a hold on a lower-court ruling that said the NFL can't force players to wait three years after high school before turning pro.
In 1971, lawyers for Detroit high school star Spencer Haywood
followed the same approach. A stay preventing Haywood from going in
the NBA draft was tossed out by Justice William O. Douglas, opening
the door for underclassmen and teenagers to play pro basketball.
"It's the exact same scenario," Milstein said in a telephone
interview with The Associated Press on Tuesday. "It just needs to play out
The NFL said the appellate decision will ultimately stand.
"There was ample support for the ruling of the 2nd Circuit,
which thoroughly considered and completely rejected the arguments
that Mr. Clarett's lawyers have presented to the Supreme Court,"
NFL executive vice president Jeff Pash said.
Williams, the heralded Southern California sophomore receiver, filed his
own lawsuit in federal court in Manhattan on Monday, saying the NFL
issued conflicting statements about eligibility for the draft which
caused him to sacrifice his college career.
If they wind up being eligible, Williams would be expected to go
in the first round of the draft, while former Ohio State tailback Clarett might not be taken
until the second or third round.
Clarett argued in Tuesday's filing that the NFL wouldn't suffer
any harm if he's allowed in the draft -- but he would be harmed if
he is blocked.
Clarett led Ohio State to a national title as a freshman, but
was ruled ineligible as a sophomore for accepting money from a
family friend and lying about it to NCAA and university
investigators. Williams declared for the draft after a lower court
ruled in Clarett's favor.
Clarett, 20 and out of high school two years, would be eligible
for the draft next year under the current rule. He dropped out of
classes at Ohio State after the winter quarter.
U.S. District Court Judge Shira Scheindlin ruled in February
that Clarett should be allowed in the draft. She said the rule
excluding him violates antitrust law and unjustly blocks a player
from pursuing his livelihood.
Ginsburg is a Clinton administration appointee who oversees
matters from the New York-based 2nd U.S. Circuit. She could decide
on her own whether to intervene or refer the issue to the full
court. She could also ask the NFL to file a response.
There is no court deadline for Ginsburg to act on the request,
but Clarett's lawyer said if no decision is rendered before the
draft Clarett "will suffer substantial irreparable injury."
If Ginsburg or the full court turns down the request, the lower
court's decision against Clarett stands.
Should the court decide against Clarett -- and by extension,
Williams -- the players could only return to play college football
if they met academic standards and their universities successfully
petitioned the NCAA for reinstatement.
Steve Snapp, an assistant athletic director at Ohio State, said
there were significant obstacles in the way of Clarett regaining
his eligibility even if he wanted to rejoin the Buckeyes.
"There is a number of issues about whether or not he has
professionalized himself," Snapp said.
The NFL also could be compelled legally to include Clarett and
Williams in a supplemental draft. Former stars such as Reggie
White, Cris Carter and Bernie Kosar entered the NFL after being
taken in supplemental drafts.
Clarett's mother said her son would continue to train as if he would be playing in the NFL.
"He's continuing to work out so his mind and body are in sync," Michelle Clarett told The Columbus Dispatch for Tuesday's editions.