Tuesday, August 17, 2004
Ruling bars Edwards from Athens for good
ATHENS, Greece -- U.S. sprinter Torri Edwards was knocked
out of the Olympics for good Tuesday when an arbitration panel
upheld her two-year drug suspension, saying she should have known
tablets provided by her doctor contained a banned substance.
Edwards had been considered a medal contender in the 100 and 200
meters at the Athens Games. She inherited the world championship in
the 100 when Kelli White forfeited that crown because of drug use.
At the U.S. Olympic trials, Edwards finished second in the 100
in 11.02 seconds, and third in the 200 in 22.39. Edwards' spot in
the 100 will go to Gail Devers, who finished fourth at the trials.
Her spot in the 200 will go to LaShaunte'a Moore.
Edwards tested positive for the stimulant nikethamide at a meet
in Martinique on April 24, but blamed the result on two glucose
tablets she took because she wasn't feeling well. She said her
team's physical therapist bought the glucose at a store on the
Caribbean island, and that she was unaware it contained any banned
The international Court of Arbitration for Sport rejected her
appeal Tuesday, one day after Edwards spoke on her own behalf
during a 5½-hour hearing.
The ruling is final. Edwards will remain suspended until July
The CAS panel said Edwards took two Coramine Glucose tablets
provided by Christopher Vincent, a licensed chiropractor who worked
for her track club, HSI. The product had a leaflet in French making
clear it contained nikethamide and carrying a warning to athletes
that it can result in a positive doping test, the panel said.
"There is an obligation and a duty for all athletes and more
particularly to top-level athletes to ensure that no prohibited
substance enters his/her body, tissues or fluids," the CAS said in
its 20-page ruling. "The panel found that Torri Edwards was
negligent in failing to enquire whether the product contained a
However, the panel added, Edwards "conducted herself with
honesty, integrity and character ... she has not sought to gain any
improper advantage or to 'cheat' in any way."
The panel said a two-year ban "may appear harsh," considering
the same penalty applies for use of steroids and the
endurance-boosting hormone EPO. But it said sports federations
should be supported in their recent adoption of the first World
If the International Association of Athletics Federations had
enacted the code two months later, Edwards would have been let off
with a public warning under the old rules.
Edwards' attorney, Emmanuel Hudson, did not immediately return
phone calls. A statement on the HSI web site said she was
"devastated" by the decision.
"We respect the fairness of the CAS system and will work with
USA Track & Field to make the necessary adjustments to our
roster," U.S. Olympic Committee spokesman Darryl Seibel said.
Edwards' suspension was announced last Wednesday by the U.S.
A U.S. arbitration panel that first heard the case said there
might have been "exceptional circumstances." But an IAAF doping
review board rejected that argument, relying on the "strict
liability" standard that declares athletes responsible for any
banned substances found in their bodies.
The IAAF said it was "very pleased" that the CAS panel had
accepted its ruling.
"It's very important that athletes realize their obligation
regarding doping," IAAF spokesman Nick Davies said. "The
credibility of the sport depends on it."
The therapist who gave the tablets to Edwards, Christopher
Vincent, was dismissed from the HSI club as a result of the case.
The ruling finally ends the drama and speculation that had
surrounded the U.S. 100-meter squad since the trials, where
defending Olympic gold medalist Marion Jones finished a shocking
fifth and newcomer Lauryn Williams outleaned Devers at the tape for
the third spot.
Five days later, Edwards acknowledged her positive drug test,
then launched the first in a series of appeals. With Edwards' spot
in jeopardy, speculation centered on whether Devers might withdraw
from the 100 to concentrate on the 100-meter hurdles. Devers is a
two-time Olympic gold medalist in the 100, but had never won a
hurdles medal, even though it's her best event.
Devers' withdrawal would have moved Jones into the 100. But
Devers, competing in her fifth Olympics, squelched that idea early
last week when she said she would run the 100.