Tuesday, October 25, 2005
Roof at Minute Maid will be open for Game 3
HOUSTON -- Major League Baseball pulled the roof out from
over the Houston Astros' heads.
Over the objections of the Astros, the commissioner's office
ordered the roof open at Minute Maid Park for Game 3 of the World
Series on Tuesday night and said all games in Houston this week are
likely to be played outdoors.
Home-field disadvantage? Baseball ordered the Astros to leave the roof of Minute Maid Park open.
"I don't think Major League Baseball should have the right to
tell us about the roof," Astros outfielder Lance Berkman said.
"They're trying to take the home-field advantage from us. I don't
think that's right."
Jimmie Lee Solomon, executive vice president of baseball
operations in the commissioner's office, made the announcement on
the field about four hours before the scheduled first pitch. The
sky was cloudless when Solomon spoke.
"We've studied weather, winds, we've studied humidity. There
isn't a cloud within 800 miles of here," baseball commissioner Bud
Selig said. "In Milwaukee, you don't get a day like this until
The gametime temperature was 61 degrees, and Selig said it would
not get too cold for fans later in the evening. He cited baseball's
decision to order the roof be opened during the 2001 World Series
at Bank One Ballpark in Phoenix.
"I need to get a new life, because I sat and watched The
Weather Channel all day determining about low temperatures, high
temperatures, medium temperatures," Selig said.
The Astros like playing with the roof closed because, among
other things, it increases the noise. They were not thrilled with
"It's almost like a road game for us now," Astros first
baseman Mike Lamb said. "We're not used to playing with it open."
It didn't seem to hurt them at the start. There was a high
decibel level at the beginning when Lance Berkman's first-inning
single put them ahead.
Selig and Solomon said the commissioner's office followed the
Astros' regular-season guidelines, which they said call for the
roof to be open when the temperature is under 80 degrees and there
is no rain. Astros spokeswoman Lisa Ramsperger said there are no
"I think it's a disregard to our fans, the comfort of our
fans," Astros manager Phil Garner said.
Solomon said that the forecast is favorable for the rest of the
week and that the roof is likely to be open for all games in
Houston. The Astros played their first five postseason games this
year with the roof closed. Solomon said the temperature was over 80
degrees for all except Game 3 of the first-round series against
"By the time we got here to look at the roof it was already
there and we could not change it in time," he said.
During the regular season, the Astros were 36-17 at home when
the roof was closed, 15-11 when it was rolled back and 2-0 in games
that began indoors and finished in fresh air. It was open just
twice after May -- for a pair of games against the Chicago Cubs
during the final series of the regular season.
"This is part of our home-field advantage and for Major League
Baseball to try and change that is either a) ridiculous or b)
they're American League fans," Astros catcher Brad Ausmus said.
Selig had a different view.
"The only factor that should determine it is weather," he
said. "We don't do things to give teams competitive advantages in
White Sox outfielder Aaron Rowand cited his experiences in the
Metrodome in Minneapolis.
"When it's packed, that place is loud. I'd doubt if it's louder
than that," he said. "Close the damn thing, it doesn't matter to
us. Everybody is making a big deal about the roof. I don't think
anybody cares whether it's closed or open."