Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Cubs sale may be helped by bankruptcy
NEW YORK -- By keeping the storied Chicago Cubs baseball team and Wrigley Field out of its bankruptcy filing, Tribune Co. gains the freedom to run the team without having to constantly consult with a judge -- and to continue soliciting bids for the Cubs and the stadium that could net $1 billion.
A sale outside of the bankruptcy process could help Tribune reap a higher price for the Cubs and ivy-walled Wrigley, analysts said, which could ultimately benefit the creditors who were put on hold by Tribune's Chapter 11 filing Monday. Still, it's not clear whether Tribune's more than 1,000 creditors would agree to leave such a prized asset outside the bankruptcy court's control.
"I'd be more concerned with the larger creditors, the banks," Gimme Credit senior analyst Dave Novosel said. "While banks typically, at least, want to be accommodating, in today's environment, they have less ability to do so, considering their own issues."
Several of Tribune's biggest lenders, including Merrill Lynch Capital Corp. and hedge fund Highland Capital, declined to comment on the Cubs.
Tribune's first hearing in bankruptcy court is scheduled for Wednesday morning in Delaware.
Operating outside the bankruptcy means the Cubs won't need to hold a bankruptcy auction, a more cumbersome process because of the checks and balances that Chapter 11 protection requires. Including the Cubs in the filing could hamper the team's ability to pursue expensive free agents, manage its farm system and quickly make deals without going to a bankruptcy judge for approval.
Tribune Co. announced on Opening Day 2007 that, besides accepting a buyout offer from real estate mogul Sam Zell, it was selling the Cubs and Wrigley Field. Since then, Tribune has moved slowly in soliciting bids and considering the potential buyers.
By June of this year, there were still nine approved bidders on the list, and in August, Zell announced the field had been narrowed to five. At least three would-be buyers have submitted second-round bids to Tribune, and a Cubs senior vice president, Crane Kenney, said last week that he expects the franchise to be sold by spring training, which begins in February.
Tribune Co. entered bankruptcy Monday, burdened by $13 billion debt. The newspaper company has 20,000 employees and owns large daily newspapers such as the Los Angeles Times, Chicago Tribune, The Hartford (Conn.) Courant and the Orlando (Fla.) Sentinel, cable channels and 23 TV stations.
On Monday, the Cubs said the bankruptcy of its parent would change very little as the team tries to finally win its first World Series since 1908. "It is business as usual at Wrigley Field as the Cubs continue to prepare for the 2009 season," a team statement said.
Even so, Standard & Poor's analyst Emile Courtney said Tuesday that Tribune would need to get bankruptcy court approval to finalize a deal.
Lisa Hill Fenning, a former judge who now is a bankruptcy attorney at Dewey & LeBoeuf LLP, said sales of sports teams are complicated because leagues and owners need to approve the winning bidder. As a result, she believes creditors will let Tribune leave the Cubs outside the bankruptcy case because selling it out of court is simpler and likely to be smoother for potential bidders. (Groups that have bid for the Cubs declined to comment Tuesday.)
"It's hard to imagine a scenario where creditors would seek to push the Cubs entity into the bankruptcy case," Fenning said.
Vendors such as the paper company Abitibi Consolidated and the White Birch Paper Co., who are now also creditors, did not comment. Tribune is a continuing customer of Abitibi.
At Tribune's bankruptcy hearing, the company will ask the court to give it permission to continue paying employees, vendors and insurance premiums. Companies in bankruptcy typically need to get a so-called debtor-in-possession loan to fund operations during the bankruptcy.
The company has also asked for approval of a financing deal with Barclays Capital that gives it continued use of a $300 million credit facility backed by collateral, for the next 120 days. On that loan, $225 million is outstanding. Tribune has also taken an additional $50 million cash-collateralized letter of credit.
While the sale of the Cubs might proceed without much hindrance, the bankruptcy has a more immediate effect on Tribune employees. Zell's buyout turned employees into the nominal owners of the company, through an employee stock ownership program that is designed to gradually gain equity in Tribune over time. That prospect is clouded now.
Further, Tribune said Monday that it would halt severance payments to recently laid-off employees, as well as deferred compensation and other payments to former workers. Essentially, ex-employees have to get in line with other creditors.
The list includes former Times Mirror Chief Executive Mark Willes. Tribune Co.'s bankruptcy filing revealed that Willes, a former cereal company executive who drew fire for cuts at Times Mirror papers and for having advertising executives work more closely with newspaper editors, is owed about $11.2 million in retirement benefits and deferred compensation.