Print and Go Back ESPN.com: Mixed Martial Arts [Print without images]

Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Freaks and geeks: Defending the circus

By Jake Rossen
Sherdog.com

Herschel Walker
And so what if former NFL player Herschel Walker did pummel a tomato can? Call it progress.

Attending a prizefighting event at a Colorado bar is not the time to anticipate great things. But even by the standards of fourth-rate promotion, the Denver-based Knockout Fights banner deserves a place in combat sports infamy.

On a night in 2004, two wheelchair-bound boxers rolled into a ring and began pummeling each other. That same evening, midgets strapped on gloves bigger than their torsos and bounced against the ropes, tiny fists crashing into tiny heads in a display for the amusement of all.

These are not arenas where nobility and respectful approximation of warfare take place. This is the land of the freak show, and people are watching -- in some cases, in greater numbers than for the real thing.

Showtime posted its second-best MMA viewership number ever -- 517,000 viewers -- for its Jan. 30 show, featuring the headlining-by-proxy fighting debut of former NFL player Herschel Walker. And then there's Kimbo Slice, a modified street fighter who participated in two of the UFC's highest-rated fights. James Toney, Ricardo Mayorga and Shannon Briggs are all boxers who plan to titillate audiences by risking their femurs against leg kicks.

Celebrity boxing? Try celebrity homicide. But the idea of contorting fight event into spectacle is hardly a new concept.

Primo Carnera, born in 1906, was a circus strongman with a bear neck and a heavy punch who was said to have been manipulated by organized crime into becoming an illegitimate ring attraction. (One opponent was reputed to have fallen to the ground six times in one round, though Carnera never appeared to actually hit him.) Rather than expel Carnera as a parody of athletics, the public loved it. He drew 75,000 people for a big fight in Mexico; 70,000 for another in England. A hulking 6-foot-5, he was a man whom audiences perceived as a superhero in the flesh: Bob Sapp's prototype.

Could Carnera box? Not really. Could he win via promotional manipulation or simply by leaning on smaller men? He could.

Carnera was followed by a fleet of boxers who carried into the ring few qualifications beyond a human-interest story: Joe Savage was a bare-knuckle boxer who was mauled by pro Bert Cooper; female kickboxer Lucia Rijker lost to a man in a Muay Thai match; Margaret McGregor fought Loi Chow, a male, and won a decision. Mike Tyson was the best of both worlds: a legitimate fighter who ran roughshod over the sports and police blotters.

All of this led, inevitably, to the most grotesque geek show of them all: pitting disparate fighting styles against each another and mopping up the blood afterward. This is what is slightly ironic about MMA's current attitude toward the sideshow: As a sport born from a circus atmosphere, it doesn't leave itself much room for comment.

Don Frye
Has mixed martial arts pioneer Don Frye forgotten where he came from?

Still, the participation of men such as Walker and Jose Canseco have riled men like Don Frye, who has chastised the sport's powers that be for giving shelter to these types of spectacles. Is Frye forgetting that the idea of a firefighter pitted against a 400-pound sack lunch in the form of Thomas Ramirez -- the first "pro" fight on Frye's résumé -- is a freak attraction at its least diluted? And what about Dana White, who scoffed at Walker while conveniently forgetting he once tried to organize a boxing match between himself and Tito Ortiz?

Rather than bemoan the oddities of combat sport, it might be more pragmatic to consider how they act as fuel for progress. When Carnera circulated, boxing had taken a nosedive after the departure of Jack Dempsey. Unskilled though he was, Carnera nonetheless reignited a passion for prizefighting. The UFC of the 1990s was nauseating, but it self-corrected and evolved into something special. If it weren't for the morbid curiosities of the paying public, Frye and White wouldn't have jobs.

Anomalies continue to intrigue us. Brock Lesnar had a decorated career as an amateur wrestler, but did the hundreds of thousands of people buying his first few fights expect to see a clinical demonstration of a pin fall -- or a grunting man-rock tossing people over the cage padding? And didn't the athletes appearing along with Lesnar benefit financially from his participation? As a sponsor paying an athlete to wear your brand, would you prefer his butt-billboard to appear on a card headlined by Lesnar or Thiago Silva?

The danger in criticizing the Herschel Walkers of the combat sports world is that it ignores the basic human-interest story. We watch fights because we have an emotional investment in the outcome, and that investment is tenfold if the athletes participating have endeared themselves in other endeavors. If you grew up watching Walker play football, you're probably going to have at least a passing interest in seeing him fight. If Jean-Claude Van Damme actually participates in a Muay Thai match -- as he has alleged to have lined up for later this year -- he will attract a sizable number of people who can quote "Bloodsport" chapter and verse.

There is a point of saturation, and inviting wheelchair-bound athletes into a beer hall is probably spilling over the overflow tube. But a man who can pass a physical, can display a reasonable aptitude in the gym to defend himself and is cognizant of the risk involved shouldn't be the victim of elitist bashing.

Instead, he should listen to the call of P.T. Barnum: He should step right up.

Jake Rossen is a contributor to Sherdog.com.