Print and Go Back 2009 [Print without images]

Sunday, April 25, 2010
Day 3 stocked with sleepers

By Christopher Harris

There has never been a single fantasy-relevant player selected on Day 3 of the NFL draft.

That, of course, is because until 2010 there had never been a Day 3 of the NFL draft. There have, in fact, been plenty of fantasy-relevant players taken in Rounds 4 through 7 of the draft, including in the past five years: Marion Barber, Brandon Jacobs, Owen Daniels, Brandon Marshall, Jerome Harrison, Marques Colston, Steve Breaston, Brent Celek, Ahmad Bradshaw, Tim Hightower, Pierre Garcon and a bunch more. Last year, Louis Murphy, Austin Collie, Johnny Knox, Bernard Scott, Julian Edelman, Sammie Stroughter and Rashad Jennings all came out of the late rounds to find their names on the lips of fantasy owners, too.

Let's take a look at Saturday's draft action, and find some names you might want to remember this summer.

Mike Williams
Mike Williams caught 49 passes for 746 yards and 6 TDs for the Orange in 2009.
101. Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Mike Williams, WR. This isn't the Mike Williams the Lions took 10th overall in '05 and then kicked to the curb two years later (and who's currently on Pete Carroll's roster in Seattle). But this Mike Williams comes with just as much baggage. He scored 10 touchdowns at Syracuse in his sophomore season, but was suspended for his junior year for violating academic policies and then quit the team and dropped out of school this past season rather than be suspended for being involved in a car accident. But he has first-round talent, and if he gets his life together, Williams could start as soon as this year, opposite Regis Benn in the flanker role. Seriously, this guy can be Brandon Marshall if he wants to be. Unfortunately, he probably doesn't want to be.

107. Buffalo Bills: Marcus Easley, WR. Easley is known as having occasionally spotty hands, but running 4.46 at 6-foot-3 and 210 pounds at the combine is impressive. He fits the mold of the big and fast wide receiver that can be a fantasy star sooner than you expect, and he lands with a Bills team that has no proven talent opposite Lee Evans. James Hardy is coming back from his knee injury and hasn't shown anything in his first two NFL seasons, and the other options are Steve Johnson and Roscoe Parrish. Easley probably needs a year to get his feet under him in pro football, but he's someone to watch in camp and the exhibition season.

112. New York Jets: Joe McKnight, RB. The Jets' selection of McKnight signaled the end of Leon Washington's time in New York. McKnight is the same kind of quick player Washington is, and can be a third-down back right now; he's got good hands and real explosiveness. However, with LaDainian Tomlinson on hand to back up Shonn Greene, there doesn't figure to be a ton of work for McKnight right away. In fact, that was going to be Washington's problem had he stayed with the Jets: he was going to focus on special teams and only occasionally work his way into the backfield. That might not have played well for an outspoken guy in a contract year, so the Jets dumped him to the Seahawks, under the assumption that the rookie McKnight will be much quieter.

113. New England Patriots: Aaron Hernandez, TE. If he's healthy, we like Rob Gronkowski more in fantasy leagues this year than Hernandez. They'll both labor for the Patriots, but whereas Gronkowski can be an in-line blocker, Hernandez can't, and in New England that doesn't fly. I won't be shocked to see Hernandez work his way into multi-receiver packages at some point this year, but honestly, the Pats need to show they're ready to throw to their tight ends much at all before you go drafting either of these guys.

114. Baltimore Ravens: Dennis Pitta, TE. I think Pitta has a better chance at unseating fellow rookie Ed Dickson than Hernandez does of toppling Gronkowski, but of course, Todd Heap is also in Baltimore, so you're probably not drafting either of the Ravens' first-year tight ends. Pitta is older (he did his BYU mission), but has Dickson's same field-stretching talent. The selections of Pitta and Dickson most likely mean this will be Heap's last season as a Raven.

Anthony Dixon
Anthony Dixon rushed for 1,391 yards and 12 scores for Miss. St.
173. San Francisco 49ers: Anthony Dixon, RB. Dixon is a monster at 6-1, 245 pounds and led the SEC in rushing yards per game (yes, he outran Heisman winner Mark Ingram), but he fell into the sixth round because scouts were apparently concerned about his lack of quickness. Dixon is a surprisingly good pass-catcher and a willing blocker, and looks like a much better fit to pair with Frank Gore than Glen Coffee was. I think you'll see Dixon on the field a significant amount in '10.

177. Cleveland Browns: Carlton Mitchell, WR. Mitchell and Marcus Easley have extremely similar measurables, meaning each of them has the body to be a No. 1 NFL receiver. This kid is 6-3, 215 pounds and ran a 4.49 40 at the combine. Whether or not Mitchell (or Easley or Mike Williams or several other big receivers drafted this weekend) can develop into a Miles Austin or Brandon Marshall comes down to passion and willingness to work, and that's something no scout can be sure about when the money starts flowing. Mitchell's landing spot, Cleveland, isn't exactly rife with proven receiving options (Mohamed Massaquoi, Brian Robiskie, Chansi Stuckey, Josh Cribbs), but Mitchell is really raw. He's a better sleeper for 2011.

180. Jacksonville Jaguars: Deji Karim, RB. The Jaguars did well to draft Rashad Jennings in the seventh round last year, as Jennings became Maurice Jones-Drew's backup and could be a bigger factor if MJD's touches are somewhat limited in '10. Now they'll try Southern Illinois' Karim, a 210-pound back who ran a 4.37 at his pro day (he wasn't invited to the combine). Karim and Jennings aren't the same kind of runner; Jennings is a much bigger man, and a pounder, so I expect him to keep his "MJD handcuff" status. But let's see how things develop in camp. Karim did suffer a torn patellar tendon in '08.

188. Pittsburgh Steelers: Jonathan Dwyer, RB. I know some "insiders" who had Dwyer rated as high as No. 4 among running backs coming into this draft, so the fact he lasted until halfway through the sixth round was a shocking development. ESPN's Adam Schefter reported after the draft that several teams had removed Dwyer from their boards because of an undisclosed medical condition, but finally the Steelers bit, and if the kid is healthy, this could be one we're talking about in a couple of years. Seriously, he was in Ryan Mathews territory just a couple of months ago. Obviously, Rashard Mendenhall is the main guy in Pittsburgh, and Mewelde Moore and Isaac Redman are also on hand. But Dwyer is already a better player than both of those backups. I wouldn't say this affects Mendenhall's fantasy value yet, but I'd love to see Dwyer work his way onto the field soon and prove his detractors wrong. There's an outside shot he could be Mendenhall's handcuff.

193. Green Bay Packers: James Starks, RB. Starks isn't a threat to Ryan Grant just yet, but I love the guy's potential to be an NFL starter in the next few years. He's a big man, at 6-2 and somewhere in the 220-pound range, and fell this far in the draft because he missed the entire '09 season with a torn labrum in his shoulder. Starks ran a 4.50 at the combine, is a good blocker and pass-catcher, and is one of those big men who somehow regularly find their way through the hole with good burst and make people miss in small spaces. He's not a burner, won't get around the corner very often, and of course, we can't be guaranteed the shoulder is right. But I nominate him as a potential No. 2 rusher in Green Bay in Week 1. Brandon Jackson has a challenger.

200. Philadelphia Eagles: Charles Scott, RB. Scott raised red flags during the scouting season when tests revealed a fractured collarbone. He's a power inside rusher who can get through the hole when one is there. I don't think NFL teams view him as an eventual starter, and he'll never be a big-play guy, but given how the Eagles have struggled to find short-yardage runners over the past few seasons, there's a chance Scott could get into the mix with bangers like Mike Bell and Leonard Weaver this year.

Christopher Harris is a fantasy analyst for He is a six-time Fantasy Sports Writing Association award winner. You can ask him questions at