Matt Brown, Wichita State Baseball
Credentials: With one out in the top of the second against Oklahoma, the freshman right fielder tracked a routine fly ball toward the fence in foul territory. Without taking his eye off the ball, he jumped up -- and over -- the shoulder-high barrier, made the catch and held on for the out.
Past ESPYs: None

Chuck Carothers
Credentials: In the X Games 10 Moto X Best Trick final, Carothers took off from the ramp and did a 360-degree body varial -- letting go of the bike and rolling his body over mid-air -- to win the gold.
Past ESPYs: None

Blake Hoffarber 
Credentials: With time running out in overtime in the Minnesota Class 4A state title game, Blake Hoffarber -- lying flat on his back across the 3-pt. line -- sank a shot to tie the game and force a second OT. Hoffarber's Hopkins High School Royals won the game 71-60.
Past ESPYs: None
(Photo credit: Dave Hill/Minesota Basketball News.)

Tiger Woods at The Masters
Credentials: After sailing his tee shot long over the par-3 16th green, and clinging to a one-shot lead, he played his chip up the slope and watched it stop, then drop into the hole for a birdie.

Past ESPYs: 2002 Best Record-Breaking Performance; 1997 Best Breakthrough Athlete; 1998 (co-winner), 2000-02 Best Male Athlete; 1998, 2000-03 Best Male Golfer; 2001 Best Championship Performance; 2001 Best Come-From-Behind Performance; 1998 Showstopper of the Year; Golf Decade Award.