Updated: October 6, 2010, 6:07 PM ET

Mahan: 'It's a great learning experience'

Harig By Bob Harig
ESPN.com
Archive

With apologies to Hunter Mahan -- who in no way should be taking the blame -- the thrilling ending to the Ryder Cup on Monday is exactly what draws us to it.

[+] EnlargeHunter Mahan
Sam Greenwood/Getty ImagesA disheveled Hunter Mahan struggled through tears at a news conference after the Americans lost the Ryder Cup on Monday at Celtic Manor.

And in a big picture sense, the outcome is really how this biennial competition should go down, a closely played match separated by the thinnest of margins with the home team prevailing.

Certainly having the home crowd must be worth at least one point -- which turned out to be the difference in the 14½-13½ outcome for Europe.

When you consider that the United States had four of the top five players in the world and seven of the top 20 compared to six of the top 20 for Europe, the competition should be the nail-biter it became Monday.

Mahan need not feel ashamed for the finish, although his gutted reaction afterward speaks to the pressure and intensity of a Ryder Cup. No individual event, even a major championship, has the same feeling, especially since a player's mistakes are celebrated so vociferously at the Ryder Cup.

Phil Mickelson and Stewart Cink admirably stuck up for Mahan when it became clear that the three-time PGA Tour winner was having difficulty answering questions in the aftermath.

This is a guy who has played with hundreds of thousands of dollars on the line and prospered but could manage just one birdie Monday and came up woefully short of the par-3 17th green when he needed the shot of his life to continue his singles match with Graeme McDowell.

That he then chunked his chip shot was the unfortunate fallout from the pressure -- did anyone really expect him to hole it? -- and no doubt it was brutal to feel the ground tremble around him as the European team and its fans celebrated at his expense.

"The Ryder Cup brings stuff out of you that you don't know you had, from an emotional sense, from a golf sense,'' Mahan said Monday night. "I don't think people give us credit for how much we actually care about it. It's not fun to lose in this event. It's not fun to watch them parade around and get a victory in their home place.

"It is one of the best events in the world, because it's different than what you usually do and what you're playing for.''

Over the years, American players have been criticized for their perceived indifference to the event, especially when they were getting hammered in consecutive Ryder Cups in 2004 and 2006.

Monday's tears from Mahan showed a different side. So did Mickelson taking the blame, acknowledging his losses in his first three matches proved to be a huge difference in the competition. And then there was Jim Furyk, who came up one hole short against Luke Donald.

"It's always been my favorite event,'' he said. "Rarely have I ever been as happy after winning; I've never cried after losing other than at the Ryder Cup.

"We know what it means to us. Whatever you all thought in the past, whatever you've all written in the past, it's your observations, the way you feel. But we know what it means.''

Fair enough. The American comeback was every bit the story as the European victory. When you considered that 10 of the 28 matches over four days got to the 18th hole, it is easy to see that the half-point separating a European celebration or an American party was minuscule.

As for Mahan, perhaps he can draw some inspiration from Bernhard Langer, whose pain at the 1991 Ryder Cup was even more severe.

The entire match came down to his putt on the 18th hole. Make it and Europe keeps the cup. Miss and it is an American victory.

Langer missed the 6-footer in his match against Hale Irwin, and the Americans celebrated at Kiawah Island.

While devastated, the German was not down for long. He won the following week on the European Tour, captured the 1993 Masters and was a victorious European captain.

"It's a great learning experience,'' Mahan said. "I take a lot for myself. I'm disappointed now, but it's not something I'm going to be disappointed with for long.''

Looking ahead

There was plenty of consternation over the weather in Wales, leading to cries for the dates of future Ryder Cups to be examined. Both the 2012 Ryder Cup at Medinah and the 2014 event at Gleneagles, Scotland, are scheduled for the same time period, the later location susceptible to the same issues experienced at Celtic Manor.

The blame for all of this has been put on the FedEx Cup, which began in 2007 and forced scheduling changes to accommodate it. In 2008, the Ryder Cup came after the third playoff event, with the Tour Championship following. This year, it was played the week following the Tour Championship.

It appears discussions will take place between the powers that be to work something out.

"We have started talking to the PGA Tour, and [commissioner] Tim Finchem has given us a commitment that the Ryder Cup will not be played later than the last week of September," said Joe Steranka, the chief executive of the PGA of America, which along with the European Tour runs the Ryder Cup. "We have put a hard-stop on that date because we believe that it will give us more flexibility to get matches finished. You can't guess the weather but if you have more daylight, then you can make up time."

The Scotland Ryder Cup would seemingly have more weather issues. Chicago can be fine in late September/early October but Scotland is susceptible to poor weather and daylight will be scarce.

But by 2014, who knows what the situation will be with the FedEx Cup? The contract runs through 2012 and a new deal will need to be negotiated as part of the PGA Tour's television contract.

So you want to play ...

Sea Island. The Seaside course is home to the first-year McGladrey Classic, the second of five Fall Series events on the PGA Tour, and is open to guest play. Several PGA Tour players make Sea Island, Ga., their home. And there is plenty of history.

Harry S. Cold and Charles Alison designed the original layout in 1929 with a Tom Fazio renovation following in 1999. The Plantation course was designed by Watler Travis and renovated by Rees Jones.

The Cloister is the high-end resort on the property, having hosted the G8 Summit in 2004. It was razed and rebuilt in 2007 and is right on the Atlantic Ocean. The Lodge is a mile away on the grounds of the golf course. Numerous packages are available that include meals, lodging, spa, etc.

The Seaside course, which has hosted numerous USGA events over the years, will play at just under 7,100 yards, par-70.

Head scratcher

When the rain turned Celtic Manor into a quagmire, there were plenty of "I told you so'' moments in Wales. October is the country's rainiest month, and many had warned that pushing the Ryder Cup back a few weeks was taking a big risk.

They were right, and were quick to point fingers at the PGA Tour's FedEx Cup. It is true that the lucrative four-tournament playoff series that concludes the FedEx Cup portion of the schedule is the main reason for moving the Ryder Cup out of its old September time slot.

Many U.K. observers were appalled. They put it off as "greed,'' seeing as the PGA Tour has no financial stake in the Ryder Cup and its players are competing for millions in bonus money -- $10 million went to winner Jim Furyk.

Greed is a strong word to throw around when you consider what the Ryder Cup is all about -- because the tournament is all about money. Lots of it. When played in Europe, it is a huge source of funding for the European Tour, which extracts a healthy fee from the host venue, in addition to sponsorship of a European Tour event.

Throw in television rights fees, corporate hospitality and the like and it is a financial windfall -- of which the players see nothing but a donation to the charity of their choice.

One of the great things about the Ryder Cup is that the players sweat so much blood for nary a dollar or pound. But to call the PGA Tour greedy seems a bit disingenuous when the Ryder Cup itself is the mother of all cash cows.

No fewer than 16 players who competed in the Ryder Cup are members of the PGA Tour. Ten of them were in Atlanta for the Tour Championship. While they certainly would love the scheduling issues to be worked out, it is hard to believe that any of them would scoff at the FedEx Cup and turn their back on it.

Bob Harig covers golf for ESPN.com. He can be reached at BobHarig@gmail.com.

ESPN Conversations


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?