ESPN the Magazine ESPN


ESPNMAG.com
In This Issue
Backtalk
Message Board
Customer Service
SPORT SECTIONS
MLB
   Scores | GameCast
NFL
   Scores
Col. Football
   Scores
NBA
   Scores
Golf
   Scores
Tennis
   Scores
Motorsports
Soccer
Boxing
NHL
M Col. BB
W Col. BB
WNBA
Horse Racing
Recruiting
Sports Business
College Sports
Olympic Sports
Action Sports
ESPNdeportes
ProRodeo
More Sports







The Life


You call that a fight?
ESPN The Magazine

Tre Johnson returned to action on Sunday after serving a one-game suspension (plus a $50,000 fine) following an altercation in last year's playoff game against Detroit. Before deciding whether Johnson's punishment fit the crime, I wish someone at the NFL would define the word "fight."

Remember the now-infamous brawl last year between Stephen Davis and Michael Westbrook? I'm sure you've seen the tape. Davis, standing helmetless on the sideline at a Redskins practice, was viciously pummeled by his teammate in a chilling display of rage. Now that was a fight -- maybe enough to warrant Westbrook's $50,000 fine.

But Johnson's so-called fight consisted of several errant punches thrown in the general direction of Lions defensive tackle Robert Porcher. Real terrifying. Aside from the fact that one of Johnson's punches accidentally grazed the head of back judge Bill Leavy, this was hardly anything to get excited about. Porcher never even got hit. This was identical to just about every other football "fight." One player grabs another's face mask, then they grapple and cuss at one another for a few seconds before an official separates them. Heated dispute? Yeah, it happens. But a fight? Don't think so.

I know: off-the-field violence is a huge concern these days. It should be. But that doesn't change the nature of the game being played on Sunday afternoons. Football is violent. Players are encouraged to hate each other. And suddenly, after the whistle blows, bloodied guys in pads and helmets are supposed to be civil? Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't each play end with someone being thrown to the ground? Vince Lombardi, the legend himself, once said that "dancing is a contact sport, football is a hitting sport."

Last year, Cleveland tackle Orlando Brown was the target of the league's ire after he shoved the official who accidentally hit him in the eye with a penalty flag. He was fined $20,000 and suspended for a game. You may not agree with Brown's actions, but surely you can understand his rage. He was fired up and focused, something happened, and he reacted. Is it just me, or isn't that what you do in a football game? It ain't a perfect world, folks. Ask Brown, who will probably never play again.

How can commissioner Paul Tagliabue and Gene Washington, who levies the fines, justify punishing someone for throwing a few wild punches on a field where destruction is the very premise? After all, football requires a particular mindset that both men should appreciate. As a former player, Washington knows that anger can't be neatly packaged between snaps. Tagliabue is a former attorney, and no one is more vicious than a lawyer.

Alan Grant, a five-year NFL veteran, covers pro football for ESPN The Magazine. To respond to his column, click here.



Latest Issue


Also See


 ESPN Tools
Email story
 
Most sent
 
Print story
 


Customer Service

SUBSCRIBE
GIFT SUBSCRIPTION
CHANGE OF ADDRESS

CONTACT US
CHECK YOUR ACCOUNT
BACK ISSUES

ESPN.com: Help | Media Kit | Contact Us | Tools | Site Map | PR
Copyright ©2002 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information are applicable to this site. For ESPN the Magazine customer service (including back issues) call 1-888-267-3684. Click here if you're having problems with this page.