Category archive: Purdue Boilermakers

NEW YORK -- Officials Brian O'Connell and Bo Boroski huddled around the monitor. They asked for more replays of a trap on Purdue's D.J. Byrd and the subsequent raised elbow that sent Villanova's Darrun Hilliard flailing back onto the court.

The two officials stepped back again, conferred and after another moment or two, called Bert Smith, the third official, to have a look. There was another conference before O'Connell finally made the call.

[+] Enlarge
D.J. Byrd
AP Photo/Jason DeCrowThis play involving Purdue's D.J. Byrd and Villanova's Darrun Hilliard turned the game around.

He signaled for a flagrant 1 on Byrd. It was his fifth foul. The Boilermakers were ahead 75-71 at the time. Villanova got two shots and the ball.

The Wildcats ended up making four free throws after another foul on Terone Johnson away from the ball.

The end result was an overtime game, which ended with Villanova pulling away and winning 89-81.

It was one semifinal on a Thursday night in mid-November. But it signified plenty for a rebuilding Purdue, a suddenly surging Villanova, and for the way in which a point of emphasis could be called in the future.

"I don't like the rule,'' said Villanova coach Jay Wright. "I don't think the refs like the rule.''

Officials have ruled that if an elbow strikes a player from the shoulders and above as he attempts to clear space then it's likely going to be called. Hilliard and Achraf Yacoubou were trapping Byrd in front of Villanova's bench. Byrd, who had played a terrific game with 16 points, was being swallowed up and had to clear an area to get a sightline to make a pass.

"It's obviously the worst thing that could happen,'' said a despondent Byrd. "The rule is if the elbow comes above where it's not supposed to then it's a flagrant 1. They got it right. It obviously wasn't intentional but that's the way the game goes.''

Byrd said he simply caught Hilliard in the wrong spot. He said he could only see Yacoubou but not Hilliard when he turned.

"I put myself in a difficult situation and it feels like that was the game,'' said Byrd. "I feel terrible.''

"I got hit,'' said Hilliard. "In the heat of the moment it didn't hurt but he caught me in the chin. Coach told me to keep my hands off him but he flung his elbow and he hit me and I fell back. It was a great call.''

The problem may not be with the call itself but more so by how long it took the officials to come up with a consensus. It wasn't conclusive on the multitude of replays and the officials spent an inordinate amount of time deciding. Purdue coach Matt Painter challenged it during the game, but didn't in the postgame. Byrd accepted responsibility.

"I didn't think it was a flagrant,'' said Johnson. "There was a lot of emotion there and we were waiting to see as they were reviewing it whether we got the call or not. We had to keep our composure.''

Purdue wasn't able to hold its ground late in the game and ultimately the physicality, which Purdue defined, turned against the Boilermakers. Purdue mirrors its coach and Painter has turned the Boilers into a gritty bunch. But losing to Bucknell at home and now to 'Nova in the 2K Sports Classic semifinals at Madison Square Garden may indicate a longer season. Purdue will fight this season, but if the Boilers can't be composed and finish games then they can't reach the top half of a loaded Big Ten.

Villanova was a complete afterthought in the Big East this season and in large part because Wright had no idea what he had. He knew freshman guard Ryan Arcidiacono was a stud if he made shots. He knew he had a strong guard who could excite the Main Line. But he had no clue if his squad -- without a preseason star -- had any toughness whatsoever.

Now he knows.

And the rest of the Big East will find out soon enough.

This was as physical a game as has been played in this brief season and the Wildcats won the fight.

"I see great potential in this group,'' said Wright. "I see a lot of work, too.''

Wright said the physicality of the Purdue game can't be duplicated in practice because 'Nova's eighth, ninth and 10th players can't come close to a team like the Boilermakers.

"No matter how much you say in practice, they don't understand it,'' said Wright. "This will be a great lesson for us. We learned you've got to be strong with every play.''

Who knows if any of the four teams at the 2K Classic will be NCAA-worthy -- Alabama outlasted Oregon State earlier. But this snapshot a week before Thanksgiving gave us a strong indicator.

Villanova grew up Thursday night. And if the Wildcats can translate that into consistent play in January and February then it might be due to the physical style they had to play to beat Purdue. There are season-changing games for teams, even this early.

We may have witnessed one for Villanova.

Purdue fans didn't want to leave Mackey Arena on Wednesday night.

Why should they have? At least, not before Robbie Hummel had a chance to speak.

[+] Enlarge
Robbie Hummel
Brian Spurlock/US PresswireRobbie Hummel was hampered by knee injuries the past two years. This season, the fifth-year senior has led the Boilermakers to a likely NCAA tournament berth.

Few players have given so much to one program.

Hummel should have played in a Final Four in his career. He probably should have been a first-team All-American. He should have spent this year playing professionally, in the NBA or overseas, as a Purdue graduate.

Instead, injuries interrupted his career, not once but twice, and robbed him of what could have been an iconic career for Purdue had he been given the opportunity to try to lead the Boilermakers to the Final Four.

"There were many times when I wondered if I would get to senior night," said Hummel. "It was so great that the fans stayed. It was a special night."

Hummel arrived in West Lafayette, Ind., as part of a celebrated freshmen class that included E'Twaun Moore and JaJuan Johnson. It was a class that served as the cornerstone for coach Matt Painter in directing the program's turnaround.

After battling a stress fracture in his back early in his career, Hummel tore his right ACL at Minnesota late in 2010, ending his season. At the time, the Boilermakers were No. 3 in the country and playing for a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament. They ended up earning a No. 4 seed and lost to top-seeded Duke in the Sweet 16.

"It's the most frustrating thing," said Hummel of his career. "I fully believe that had I not gotten hurt that we would have gone to the Final Four. We had the team to do it. We were about to be ranked No. 1."

Hummel tore his right ACL again the following October in his first practice of the season. He didn't play in 2010-11, and Johnson and Moore finished their careers without a Final Four appearance.

"For a while there, I thought I wouldn't make it," Hummel said of finishing his career. "All it takes is one movement and it could happen again. But luckily, the second surgery, they did a very good job. The trainers did a very good job."

He said it was hard knowing he wouldn't finish his career alongside Moore, with whom he had played since his sophomore year in high school, and Johnson, with whom he had played since the summer before college.

Hummel could have graduated last year, but he didn't want to dive into a time-consuming graduate business school program. He opted to pick up minors in communications and marketing and will get his undergraduate degree this spring.

The Boilermakers have survived some major distractions with the dismissal of Kelsey Barlow and the suspension of D.J. Byrd. After winning at Michigan on Feb. 25, the Boilermakers have all but sealed an NCAA tournament bid.

Hummel has been the team's leader and its top contributor with 16.8 points and seven boards a game. The balance is in place with Lewis Jackson, a double-figure scorer, on the perimeter and Ryne Smith making shots.

This team doesn't have a back-line defender of Johnson's quality but is capable of grinding out a win in the Big Ten tournament and being a tough out in the NCAAs.

"We're playing extremely well, and we're happy to be considered a lock to be in the tournament right now," Hummel said. "We're trying to improve our seed as much as possibly with a win at Indiana [Sunday]. It's big for us, and in the Big Ten tournament, anything can happen."

Few high-major players will appreciate being in the NCAAs this season as much as Hummel. He hasn't played in the postseason since his sophomore year.

"I appreciate playing in those games. It's always been fun, and it shows just how tough it is to get in the field," he said. "I say that because of what happened. I appreciate it more than I thought I would."

Hummel got a standing ovation at Mackey Arena. He should get an applause wherever his career ends in the NCAAs. He's been as good for the game as any player in the country the past five years.

Imagine watching the Purdue-Xavier game with no sound on Saturday.

All you see is Robbie Hummel, knee braces on both legs, grabbing his left hamstring and hobbling.

Then, a few minutes later, you glance up and see that Hummel is back on the floor, the far corner of the court, writhing in pain. Trainers have emerged, rubbing his legs with ice packs in hopes of getting him some relief.

The sound didn't need to be on -- and it wasn't in the ESPN studios on Saturday afternoon -- to understand that Hummel was in serious duress. But the pain was coming from cramps rather than his knees again.

[+] Enlarge
Hummel
Frank Victores/US PresswirePurdue held its collective breath when Robbie Hummel initially went down against Xavier.

Hummel had full body cramps. He was done for the final minute, when Xavier's Tu Holloway hit a 3-pointer to give the Musketeers an improbable 19-point comeback win.

There is a natural trepidation when you see Hummel on the court and in pain after all he's dealt with the previous two seasons. He tore his right ACL at Minnesota in February 2010, derailing a potential Final Four run by the Boilermakers. He then tore the same ACL again on the first day of practice in the fall of 2010 -- just as he was preparing to make a comeback in his senior season. With Hummel rejoining classmates JaJuan Johnson and E'Twaun Moore, Purdue had high hopes for the season.

Since Hummel has tendinitis in his left knee, he wears knee braces on both legs.

Hummel worked hard to return for his fifth season in college and lead a younger Purdue team as the senior statesman in a deep Big Ten. There is no reason the Boilermakers can't make a run to the NCAA tournament again. But the appearance of another injury to Hummel just shows how fragile his career has been and how much Purdue needs him to stay healthy for the Big Ten race. Hummel said the braces aren't cumbersome. And he isn't thinking about his knee injuries -- not one bit.

"I had been sick the whole week,'' said Hummel. "It was one of those things where my arms and hamstrings and my quads and my back, almost every muscle in my body [was cramping up]. I had never had that happen before. It was a first. I had cramps before but nothing to that extent.''

Hummel scored 17 points in 35 minutes in the 66-63 loss. He hit a 3-pointer to give the Boilermakers a 16-point lead in the second half and said he started cramping at the 17- or 18-minute mark. The cramp started in his left arm and then hit his calves. He went to the bench to get Gatorade and salt, but it got progressively worse.

"I knew it was cramps,'' said Purdue coach Matt Painter. "The only decision I had to make was should I keep him in the game. I shouldn't. He could barely move. He was on fumes. I asked him if he could go and obviously he said yes. But it didn't help us to have him in there. The last thing I wanted to have him have were full-body cramps. I had never been in that situation, never seen someone with full body cramps. That can be pretty dangerous, and he could have another injury while that's going on.''

Hummel said he wished he could have finished the game. And if he didn't have the cramps, he is convinced there would have been a different outcome.

"I wasn't very effective in those last 10 minutes because I was cramping,'' Hummel said. "I had a lot of confidence, and it's unfortunate that it happened."

Painter said Hummel hadn't practiced much the previous week due to being sick.

"He's a competitor and he lost so much [in games played due to injuries] that everything means so much to him, and at times he has to relax and play and let the game come to him,'' Painter said. "Right now, I've seen subtle improvements. He's still struggling to rebound there and has a tough time piecing everything together. But he's shooting the ball real well. I still want him to be aggressive.''

Hummel said he understands he has to rebound better in traffic and elevate better to get the boards. But he is confident that his shooting stroke is fine. He is averaging 18.8 points and 5.1 rebounds and shooting 44.4 percent overall (42.1 percent on 3s).

"All of that is behind me,'' Hummel said of the knee injuries. "I feel great.''

Purdue is off to a 7-2 start, with its only losses coming against Alabama in the Puerto Rico Tip-Off final and at Xavier. The Boilermakers host Western Carolina at Mackey Arena on Wednesday night.

"The last two years there was a lot of hype around our team and deservedly so,'' Hummel said. "We have a talented group this year and we're under the radar, and for the first 35 minutes you could see how we can play. Unfortunately, we didn't finish and we missed an opportunity. But it's encouraging that we were leading like that for that much time.''

Painter said the Boilermakers could be even better, especially defensively.

"We were up 19 points with 10 minutes to go, but we weren't very good at the end and got caught, missing layups and some basic things like taking care of the basketball,'' Painter said. "We've got a lot of room for improvement. We've got to be tougher and more grimy on the defensive end and get the 50-50 balls. We have to be patient but patiently aggressive. I think we can be a lot better.''

LAKE BUENA VISTA, Fla. -- Quick hitters after talking to several coaches here at the AAU nationals:

• The U.S. World University Games team -- led by Purdue coach Matt Painter (U.S. team head coach) along with Butler coach Brad Stevens and Tennessee coach Cuonzo Martin (U.S. assistants) -- continues to lose key players. Xavier's Tu Holloway turned down the invite to stay and play with his XU teammates. Wisconsin's Jordan Taylor is having minor ankle surgery. And now Painter said that UConn forward Alex Oriakhi is also out in order to rest an injury. Stevens said losing Oriakhi will be a big blow since the team that heads to China next month for the competition needs a rebounder like him in the tournament. Painter said Detroit's Ray McCallum Jr. and UConn's Shabazz Napier were added to the tryout list. Pitt's Ashton Gibbs and Syracuse's Scoop Jardine are still on the roster and are certainly favored to make the squad.

• There are still 22 players trying to make the U.S. squad and they'll compete and train in Colorado Springs from Aug. 4-7. The event runs Aug. 13-22 in Shenzhen, China. A number of players could use this international stage as a springboard for their college seasons; these players include Alabama's JaMychal Green, Texas A&M's Khris Middleton, Kentucky's Darius Miller, Northwestern's John Shurna, Minnesota's Trevor Mbakwe, Vanderbilt's John Jenkins, Michigan State's Draymond Green, Missouri's Kim English and Marcus Denmon and Notre Dame's Tim Abromaitis.

But perhaps more than any other player, Cincinnati's Yancy Gates needs to make this team and show he can be a force in order for the Bearcats to continue their rise in the Big East. Last season, he was suspended for a game due to team-related issues. Cincinnati coach Mick Cronin said Gates can come out of this looking like a team player and a stronger player who can change his image with a positive performance in China.

• Painter said fifth-year senior Robbie Hummel is tired of answering questions about his right knee (ACL surgery). And so are the Boilermakers. He said Hummel should be good to go once the season starts. Meanwhile, the Boilermakers are troubled by the foot surgery for John Hart that will keep him out for an extended period. Hart has had trouble with his right foot for quite some time.

• Villanova coach Jay Wright said JayVaughn Pinkston has been cleared by the school to play for the Wildcats this season. Pinkston was not allowed to play last season due to an assault charge. He was expected to have a major impact on last season's team prior to the incident. The Wildcats are prepping for a trip to Amsterdam, where they will play a few national teams. Wright said the Wildcats will be much different than any squad he's coached in recent years, with the team centered more around big men rather than being guard-oriented.

[+] Enlarge
Michigan's John Beilein
Kevin C. Cox/Getty ImagesJohn Beilein is looking forward to the two new guards he'll have on campus this season.

• Michigan coach John Beilein said the addition of freshmen guards Trey Burke and Carlton Brundidge should allow Stu Douglass to return to his natural off-guard position. Losing Darius Morris to the NBA draft was a huge blow to the Wolverines, but Tim Hardaway Jr. showed with the U-19 team in Latvia that he can create quite well with the ball in his hands. If the freshmen can be facilitators and Douglass can play off them, the Wolverines may not take a step back. Michigan is in the Maui Invitational in a loaded field, has to travel to upstart Virginia in the ACC-Big Ten Challenge, and gets a sleeper Big 12 team at home in Iowa State. The Wolverines are likely going to add a nonconference game at Arkansas that will take place during the Big Ten season.

• While on a recruiting trip in February, North Carolina coach Roy Williams took a side trip to an aircraft carrier in San Diego to see what it would be like in advance of the Carrier Classic on Nov. 11 against Michigan State. The USS Carl Vinson will be the host of the game, but it wasn't the ship that Williams toured. Williams wanted to see how this would work with a game on top of the ship deck. He couldn't get over the narrow passageways through the ship and wondered how his taller players would maneuver through the ship to get to the deck. Well, apparently there will be a lift that will help that occur so that shouldn't be a problem.

• Williams isn't ruling out Leslie McDonald coming back this season from an ACL injury. Williams said McDonald will have surgery on Aug. 3 and made it clear there's no reason to make any declarative statements at this juncture about a return.

• There was no consensus among the coaches in Orlando about whether to add a stipend, how it would be handled and how it could be divided up for all student-athletes. UConn's Jim Calhoun and Louisville's Rick Pitino said they would like to see $75 to $100 a week for the athletes -- roughly $400 a month.

• Not one coach endorsed the NCAA's new draft early-entry withdrawal date of April 10, 2012, after which no player will be allowed to enter the NBA draft. Makes you wonder why this was passed. Every coach who discussed it said it would lead to more poor decisions of players leaving early.

• Ole Miss coach Andy Kennedy tossed out this prediction about Vanderbilt: The Commodores are a Final Four contender.

• Old Dominion coach Blaine Taylor has gone to the Fred Hill makeover school. Hill, the former Rutgers head coach and current Northwestern assistant, was bald when he was head coach of the Scarlet Knights. Now he's gone with long hair in the back and new glasses. As for Taylor, he got rid of his famed mustache and dark hair. He's gone with something of an auburn or almost light red look. He was standing to the side of our TV set, and I wasn't the only one who had no idea who he was until you could read ODU on his golf shirt.

• Stanford is prepping for a trip to Spain in early September. The Cardinal and coach Johnny Dawkins need to get away to figure out who will stand out for them now that Jeremy Green is gone.

• New Fairfield coach Sydney Johnson squeezed in a team trip to Italy next month, which will be critical for him to get to know his players more and see how Boston College transfer Rakim Sanders meshes with a team that won the MAAC regular-season title last season and is back almost in full.

• The travel some of these coaches put on themselves is a bit ridiculous. Dawkins was in Orlando on Monday, then took off for Phoenix and then Los Angeles before he headed back to Orlando by Thursday. Temple coach Fran Dunphy was in Orlando on Monday and was off to Phoenix before a return to Orlando by the end of the week.

• New Maryland coach Mark Turgeon said he has reviewed his team enough to know that scoring up front will be a challenge. He said he'll likely go with four guards on the court on a consistent basis.

• Northwestern's Bill Carmody clearly wanted to be noticed in showing his school spirit. He had a rather loud pair of purple sweat pants that I'm not sure you could or would want to buy at the campus bookstore. Michigan State's Tom Izzo went with Spartan green, which Carmody pointed out, but the green was certainly more muted than the purple.

Quick thoughts for the final week of the regular season:

• If Kansas State continues on its current pace and finishes in third place in the Big 12, why shouldn't Frank Martin be coach of the year in the league? Martin has dealt with multiple suspensions and defections and has the Wildcats positioned to be a threat to win the Big 12 conference tournament and go into the NCAAs on quite a high.

Even though it took until late in the season, Martin got Jacob Pullen to become the leader he needed him to be for the Wildcats. Martin is pushing the right buttons with this squad at the right time and, ultimately, isn't that how a coach should be judged? How a team finishes, not just how it starts, should be part of the criteria.

• Brigham Young's Jimmer Fredette is the leader for national player of the year. Why isn't Dave Rose getting similar attention for national coach of the year? Rose has the Cougars in position to nab a No. 1 seed or at the very least a No. 2. The Cougars have become a solid interior defensive team as evidenced by how they handled San Diego State on Saturday and they've been calm, cool and collected in hostile road games throughout Mountain West play. Rose has BYU on the verge of a historic season. He's also coached and developed Fredette into a star.

• I'd love to hear from the selection committee if wins over Duke by Florida State and Virginia Tech were the deciding factors in admitting them into the Dance. St. John's didn't need just its win over Duke to earn a bid. But will the Duke win be all the Seminoles and Hokies have to show on their résumés? The numbers may add up for selection but how much of that bid would be based on beating Duke?

• We had an interesting debate on our Experts show Tuesday about comparing middling high majors with conference champs from lower-tier leagues with a gaudy record. Belmont would be an interesting team to watch if the Bruins (19-1 in the Atlantic Sun, 27-4 overall) were to lose in the conference championship. They likely wouldn't get a bid but could be a first-round upset team if they make the tournament.

• The Colonial may be the most competitive conference tournament outside of the power six. The top four seeds -- George Mason, Old Dominion, VCU and Hofstra -- are all capable of winning the event in Richmond, Va. Drexel, the No. 5 seed, has shown that it can beat anybody in the league as well as lose to just about anybody. The winner of this tournament will be battle-tested for a first-round NCAA tournament matchup. A George Mason-ODU final would be an NCAA-caliber type affair.

• We chose our most disappointing teams on the Experts show Tuesday. Michigan State is an easy answer. But I believed Northwestern would make the Dance this season. That's the second time I've predicted Northwestern would make the field (last season being the first). The Wildcats didn't make it then, they won't make now -- they had a number of chances to win quality games and whiffed.

• WCC commissioner Jamie Zaninovich is on quite a roll of late. He lured BYU into the WCC after a deal with the WAC fell apart and he's getting the Cougars after what could be a historic season in Provo. This week he was named to a five-year term on the NCAA tournament selection committee, beginning in the fall. Zaninovich joins LSU athletic director Joe Alleva as the new members on the committee.

• Purdue's JaJuan Johnson has to be a first-team All-American. And if Purdue ends up tied with Ohio State for the Big Ten title then why shouldn't he be Big Ten Player of the Year over Ohio State's Jared Sullinger?

• A month ago Connecticut's Jim Calhoun and Kemba Walker looked like the coach and player of the year in the Big East. Now, I don't think Calhoun will win the award with St. John's Steve Lavin, Louisville's Rick Pitino, Notre Dame's Mike Brey and Pitt's Jamie Dixon ahead of him. Meanwhile, St. John's Dwight Hardy and Notre Dame's Ben Hansbrough may have the inside track on Big East Player of the Year.

• Long Beach State coach Dan Monson was relieved when he left Minnesota in 2006. He was able to secure the best job in the Big West and now has a league title. Minnesota continues to be a tough place to coach, as Tubby Smith has learned.

• Conference USA is highly competitive from top to bottom. But that doesn't mean it should get more than one bid. If forced to choose the stronger conference between the CAA and C-USA, I'd go with the CAA -- it will have more bids and a better chance to advance in the tournament.

• If there is one team that should be in a better position now it's Washington State. The Cougars crushed Washington in Seattle and secured the season sweep of the Huskies. But Wazzu shouldn't be 8-8 in the Pac-10. The Cougars had a chance to beat Kansas State at home in December and lost, beat Gonzaga and Baylor, and then lost to Butler in the Diamond Head Classic final. But Wazzu couldn't beat Arizona at home, lost at Oregon, and had befuddling losses to Stanford at home and at Arizona State. Wazzu has been the most erratic team in the Pac-10 and yet could end up winning the Pac-10 tournament.

COLUMBUS, Ohio -- Purdue coach Matt Painter had never seen his team play with so little discipline, toughness and intelligence this season.

As Painter headed back on the court Tuesday night for the second half, he was at a loss for how to explain the Boilermakers' stunning 20-point halftime deficit.

His opinion didn't change much after the game ended, a stunningly embarrassing 87-64 loss to top-ranked Ohio State.

"I wish it was something from a strategic standpoint that I could look in the mirror and make a correction," Painter said. "I told our team when people across the country think about Purdue, the first thing they think about is toughness. That was the case. We've got to go back to square one from a competing standpoint."

The Big Ten, much like the Big East has been, can be unforgiving. Wasn't it just two days earlier that Purdue looked like a real Big Ten title contender by beating Michigan State by double-digits in front of a crazed crowd at Mackey Arena?

[+] Enlarge
Purdue V. OSU
Greg Bartram/US PresswirePurdue simply couldn't get anything going against Ohio State.

"It was uncharacteristic," said Purdue senior forward JaJuan Johnson, who was essentially the Boilermakers' offense in Columbus. "Lot of it is mental. We did things we didn't traditionally do."

The Buckeyes drilled 11 3-pointers, including even one from Jared Sullinger. The Bucks shot better than 50 percent overall and on 3s. They crushed Purdue on the boards, too. If you were to take a snapshot of this game, you'd be fairly certain the Boilers could not catch Ohio State in the Big Ten this season.

But this was just a snapshot -- a horrible outing for the Boilermakers but hardly an indicator of what this team is capable of, going forward. Purdue is facing the gauntlet of its Big Ten schedule.

Minnesota is up next on Saturday, with trips to Wisconsin and Illinois over the next three games before UW and Ohio State come to West Lafayette.

But with Minnesota trying to win without injured senior guard Al Nolen, Illinois having lost three of its past four and Michigan State dismissing Korie Lucious for yet another distraction, the only team left outside of the Boilermakers capable of challenging Ohio State is Wisconsin.

The Badgers still play Ohio State twice -- in Madison on Feb. 12 and here in Columbus on March 6.

"It's definitely possible for us, but we're going to have to need help from another team," Johnson said of catching Ohio State now that Purdue is two games behind the Buckeyes. "We're definitely going to need help from another team, but it's possible."

"It's awfully tough to beat them in their backyard," Painter said. "It'll be interesting. Someone is going to have come in here and beat them. But teams have proven like Minnesota and Penn State that they can get it close, but no one has been able to get over the hump yet. There are still 10 games left to play. Last year, Michigan State started 9-0 and we were able to catch them and so was Ohio State. But if they play like this, nobody will catch them."

Even with an unbalanced schedule, the Big Ten regular-season title is cherished, maybe more so than any other conference. Ohio State is a lock for a No. 1 seed if it wins the league title. OSU coach Thad Matta said earlier in the day that he didn't think the Buckeyes can go undefeated, believing that the conference is too tough to do something of that nature.

As for Purdue, this performance was so not the norm for the Boilermakers that it's hard to single out one reason. Purdue hasn't had an issue finding scoring lately, even beyond Johnson and E'Twaun Moore. But this team had never been a complete no-show defensively.

The Boilers have been one of the feel-good stories of the season with their play sans Robbie Hummel. Hummel, who is out for the year with an ACL injury, said he would consider playing for Painter in the World University Games in China in August if he's healthy. Painter said the decision will be up to his family since he has gone through two ACL surgeries.

For now, Hummel's role is to be a mentor and motivator for the younger players on this team. They'll need it now more than ever. Johnson and Moore have to be leaders to ensure that this game is forgotten and the Boilermakers move on as though this never happened.

"This was all mental," Moore said. "We've got to stay together. We know we have more good ball games to come."

Nevertheless, the snapshot now says Purdue is tied with Wisconsin, two games behind Ohio State and no longer with momentum. The Badgers, coming off a drilling of Northwestern in Evanston, Ill., need to beat Penn State on Saturday to stay in stride with Purdue and just behind Ohio State with two shots left against the Bucks.

But if Tuesday is an indication, the only real race in the Big Ten might be for second place.

The Big Ten is seven or eight deep in potential NCAA tournament teams. The ACC has Duke and a host of teams that are hard to discern from No. 2 on down.

So of course the Big Ten will capture the ACC/Big Ten Challenge, right?

Not quite. Virginia revealed the unpredictability of this event on Day 1. The Cavaliers were expected to be battling at the bottom of the ACC and Minnesota, even with senior point guard Al Nolen out of the game due to injury, was expected to walk over the Cavs after winning the Puerto Rico Tip-Off last week.

[+] Enlarge
Joe Harris
AP Photo/Tom OlmscheidJoe Harris' 24 points led Virginia to a surprising win over Minnesota on Monday night.

Instead, Virginia won 87-79 in Minneapolis, which might help the ACC win the event because it has advantageous matchups with top-ranked Duke hosting Michigan State, Clemson hosting Michigan, Virginia Tech hosting Purdue, Maryland visiting a weak Penn State team and toss-up ACC home games that include Iowa-Wake Forest and Indiana-Boston College, plus a potential upset if Florida State can beat Ohio State in Tallahassee.

For the sake of argument, that would mean home Big Ten victories by Northwestern (vs. Georgia Tech), Illinois (vs. North Carolina) and Wisconsin (vs. NC State) wouldn't even be enough to offset an ACC victory.

But regardless of what occurs, the ACC/Big Ten Challenge has provided an opportunity for a number of teams -- the opportunity to right a loss in an early-season tournament and/or pick up a much-needed quality win.

"We're all trying to figure ourself out now,'' Illinois coach Bruce Weber said. "Whether you're coming off a big win or a loss. Now you've got Big Ten, high-level games with a lot of attention. It's a good test for your team to figure out if you're for real or not. Your season can go in a lot of different ways. It's a good test to see how your team will respond, whether it's off a loss or a win.''

Florida State lost at home Sunday to Florida. The Seminoles could erase that with a win over second-ranked Ohio State, which has already won at Florida. Wisconsin is hosting NC State after losing to Notre Dame on Sunday in the final of the Old Spice Classic. The Badgers had already lost at UNLV. NC State dropped the title game of the Charleston Classic to Georgetown. Both teams could use a quality nonconference win.

Northwestern is undefeated and hoping to go to the NCAA tournament for the first time. But if the host Wildcats are to be taken seriously, shouldn't they beat Georgia Tech, which lost at Kennesaw State? Maryland failed to win a 2K Sports Classic game in New York against Pitt and Illinois. So if the Terps are a real threat to finish second in the ACC, shouldn't they win at struggling Penn State?

Purdue is fresh off a loss to Richmond in the final of the Chicago Invitational, and Virginia Tech lost Sunday night to UNLV in the final of the 76 Classic. The Hokies had already lost at Kansas State on Nov. 16. The combination of ensuring enough prep time and cost containment led Virginia Tech to chip in with Tulsa for a charter flight on the way to and from Anaheim. Hokies coach Seth Greenberg said the plane dropped Tulsa off early Monday morning. The Hokies arrived in Blacksburg at 8 a.m. after playing the night before against UNLV. The importance of the Purdue game pushed Greenberg to secure the flight.

Virginia Tech opened the season at home against Campbell, then went to Kansas State and UNC Greensboro (at Greensboro Coliseum, site of the ACC tournament) before visiting Anaheim for three games. The Hokies play Purdue at home, host Virginia to open the ACC schedule, host Penn State and then play Mississippi State at the Atlantis resort on Paradise Island in the Bahamas. This will be the first game heralded newcomer and Bulldogs center Renardo Sidney is eligible.

"This is a big stretch for us,'' Greenberg said. "The pre-Thanksgiving tournaments might make more sense when you're in the ACC/Big Ten Challenge. But we wouldn't get a Purdue to come to Blacksburg if it weren't for the Challenge. That's part of the culture. It's part of the business. Anytime you're playing an opponent like this, it's an opportunity. It sounds crazy now in November, but you're building your profile and your résumé.

"These games don't hurt you, but they can sure help you.''

He's right. So far, Virginia Tech has played three games against possible NCAA teams and lost two (Kansas State and UNLV) and the one it won (Oklahoma State) is a bubble team at best at this point. That's why a game against Purdue takes on even more significance, regardless of what event it is folded into. The Hokies won't get much bang out of a win over Penn State at home, leaving a neutral-site tilt against Mississippi State as their last significant nonconference game.

Virginia Tech knows all too well that it can't rely solely on the ACC getting its profile up to earn a potential at-large berth.

Duke and Michigan State, the opponents in the headline game in this event, will be fine either way. Both schools will be in the field, possibly as No. 1 seeds, and they'll play enough quality teams to place too much emphasis on this one game.

That's not the case for the other games.

North Carolina (lost two games in Puerto Rico) can turn its season around with a win at Illinois and a game against Kentucky at home Saturday.

Illinois beat Maryland and follows the Carolina game with a matchup in Seattle against Gonzaga on Saturday. Playing Missouri in St. Louis in a few weeks will create another opportunity for a quality win before the loaded Big Ten schedule.

"This is like a Big Ten week for us,'' Weber said. "We had a little test in New York. Now we have another test this week. These are really good games for us. We're at home. You hope you can win. But there are no guarantees.''

Just ask Minnesota, which appeared to be the one lock for the Big Ten when it hosted Virginia. The Cavs didn't see it that way.

No guarantees indeed.

Purdue has time to figure out life without Robbie Hummel, but the first week of the post-Hummel season has produced a few certainties for coach Matt Painter.

[+] Enlarge
JaJuan Johnson
Joe Robbins/Getty ImagesJaJuan Johnson and E'Twaun Moore will take on many of Robbie Hummel's responsibilities.

Hummel, the senior forward and Big Ten player of the year candidate, tore his right ACL last Saturday, the second time he has done so in the past eight months. He's done for the season, but the Boilermakers are hardly out as a Big Ten title or national championship contender.

The team's defensive identity won't change, even if it means different faces taking on some of the more crucial roles.

They still have two of the better players at their respective positions in senior forward JaJuan Johnson and wing E'Twaun Moore. When Hummel went down on Feb. 24 in a win at Minnesota, the Boilermakers had to adjust on the fly and did so quite well, winning two of the final three games of the regular season, beating Northwestern in the Big Ten title game and rebounding from a blowout loss to Minnesota by beating Siena, Texas A&M in the NCAA tournament before losing to Duke.

"Coaches play the best players and they'll step up," Painter said. "We lost a big guy in Rob. He was like a big guard. He could rebound the basketball."

Painter said he's tinkering with the idea of moving Johnson to power forward and starting Travis Carroll or Sandi Marcius at center. He also could move in Patrick Bade in the post and slide Johnson to a face-up power forward. He also may put D.J. Byrd on the floor as a stretch 4, even though he's undersized at 6-foot-5. Losing Hummel has Painter pondering various combinations to utilize Johnson even more effectively.

Hummel's responsibilities "shift to JaJuan," Painter said. "We'll be dealing with him at different positions on offense in the post or on the perimeter. But I think you'll see him double-teamed more, especially when he's in the post."

That means players such as Lewis Jackson and Kelsey Barlow and Moore, need to be ready to make shots on the perimeter if Johnson can pass out of the post. The abilities of Byrd, John Hart, Anthony Johnson and Ryne Smith to make shots will also come into play.

"We'll have to make shots to keep everybody honest," Painter said.

Hummel's injury, as well as the loss of Chris Kramer to graduation, means the Boilermakers will have to get even tougher on defense.

"I just think that our defense will continue to be something we hang our hat on," Painter said. "We won't be as potent offensively without Hummel. But we can be as good defensively. We'll look to push the basketball up but we still need to take care of the ball. We still can be very stingy and take people out of what they want to do."

Painter said Moore, Jackson and Barlow can collectively replace Kramer's defensive intensity and pressure the ball. He's expecting Hart and Smith to chip in as well.

Hummel will have surgery once the swelling goes down and has committed to coming back next season, though his time with seniors Johnson and Moore will be over.

"We've had good practices since he's been gone," Painter said. "We have to continue to create that environment. We can't go out and feel sorry. Ultimately we feel bad for Rob, but he'll be OK. We've still got two guys who have the opportunity to be All-Americans, and that's not a bad start."

The Boilermakers' two toughest nonconference games are on the road -- at Virginia Tech (Dec. 1) and at West Virginia (Jan. 16) -- and the Big Ten schedule is unforgiving, with the Boilermakers playing everyone twice except bottom-dweller Michigan and likely bubble team Northwestern. That means two games against Michigan State, Ohio State, Illinois, Minnesota and Wisconsin.

Last season, the Boilermakers went 2-3 to start the Big Ten and then won 10 straight.

"It's going to be tough for everybody," Painter said. "Hopefully in practice, and in exhibition games and in the nonconference I'll have the answers to the same questions you're asking."

Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski was one of many in a chorus of coaches this week who felt awful for Hummel, but praised Painter's coaching and Purdue's ability to be a contender in last season's NCAA tournament without him.

But it's hard to ignore how fragile a season can be when it appears everything is in place for a title run.

"You think you've got everything lined up," Painter said. "And then the basketball gods will adjust it."

Heat of summer

Horizon League commissioner Jon LeCrone, like Atlantic 10 commissioner Bernadette McGlade, who wants to tweak -- not necessarily eliminate -- summer recruiting.

LeCrone said the first vote that was taken at the Conference Commissioners Association meeting at the Big Ten's headquarters in suburban Chicago last month was to eliminate summer recruiting. That vote went 27 for, two against and four abstained. McGlade said she couldn't remember whether she was against or abstained from that vote. But then a second vote was taken after discussing it with an NCAA staffer that there might be a need to ask for an overall review. That vote went 31-0, and as stated in the minutes from the meeting that were read to ESPN.com, the CCA recommended that the board of directors consider a new recruiting model that would not include summer recruiting beginning in 2012. That last vote, with everyone agreeing that the board of directors should consider a new model that doesn't have summer recruiting, was passed on to the board of directors for the Oct. 28 meeting in Indianapolis. The National Association of Basketball Coaches sent out an urgent memo Tuesday imploring its coaches to tell their presidents to vote against any recommendation that eliminates the summer recruiting period.

But since the CCA's vote, McGlade said the A-10 has written a letter to the board because it is one of the conferences that doesn't have a voting member, saying it does not favor scrapping the entire summer. McGlade said that the A-10 wants a review of the summer, though.

Reaction at the SEC media day in Birmingham on Thursday was mixed toward the prospect of a new recruiting model that wouldn't include July.

"We're trying to be cost effective and that goes against that in July," new Auburn coach Tony Barbee, a former head coach at UTEP. "You can go one stop and see a thousand players and now talking about singular trips and you're going to add a cost. I think they're trying to take a negative influence out of our game. They thought taking away the spring would do that and now the summer? We have to sit back and evaluate the entire process and look at how we need to structure our recruiting. But eliminating July recruiting doesn't have any positive impact on our game."

Ole Miss coach Andy Kennedy said he was against scrapping July.

"I would have never seen Chris Warren since we were recruiting another player at the time," Kennedy said. "It happens all the time."

"It would be like old school in the '80s when the assistant coaches would be recruiting coordinators that you would never see," Kennedy said.

Arkansas coach John Pelphrey said he was concerned about the ability to get to multiple places on a private plane. If April is gone, take away July, then "how are we going to find out who can play against high-level competition? You're not going to see it. It's a big piece. We're being held more accountable for knowing a young man and the value of that is going up and you're giving me less opportunity to find out. You better pick the right guy. It better work out but you're giving us less time to get to know him. Some can get on a private plane to do it. When I was at South Alabama that wasn't going to happen."

Florida's Billy Donovan said he'd like to see coaches be on campus in July working out with their players Monday-Friday and then go to an AAU event Friday-Sunday. He said he could see doing that over a three- or four-week period.

"Once the season starts, I want to be with my guys," Donovan said. "Our freshmen came on campus and I wasn't there [in July]. They've got to do something to protect the players from going out to Chicago, Las Vegas, Los Angeles and IMG to work out with these workout guys [who are usually tied to agents]."

SEC commissioner Mike Slive told ESPN.com's Dana O'Neil that coaches have expressed concern about summer recruiting. Slive said legislation will come into play that allows coaches to work out their own players next summer if they're in summer school and "if we're going to have access to their players then that's where the coaches should be. We recommended not summer recruiting in the summer 2012 and then take it to their constituents to develop a new recruiting model."

Slive said there wasn't conversation with the coaches prior to the conference commissioners' decision.

"I'd rather work with my guys," Kentucky coach John Calipari said. "They want to see the best players against the players to make an evaluation. If you go to a high school game against 6-2 guys it's hard to judge. I need him in an environment to judge. There was one camp -- Five Star -- or else you went to the high school. Now a kid goes to Orlando and has an unbelievable night but gets recruited two levels above and then that guy transfers. They say there will be more transfers? There might be less."

But Calipari said he would support the NABC's position.

"But I'd rather be with my kids, working them out, and my own family," Calipari.

Georgia's Mark Fox said he's not completely opposed to eliminating summer recruiting but won't support it until he finds out what else the coaches get back -- like a four-day window in June and more time in April. "I don't think you can completely eliminate the chance to mass evaluate," Fox said. "That would be unfair to the schools that can't afford to recruit."

Miami coach Frank Haith said Thursday that coaches would like to see a compromise of some sort with two seven-day periods in July, instead of two 10-day periods. Two weeks and then it's over. We'll see what the board of directors decides next week.

Editor's Note: Andy Katz's revised top 25 was published on Friday with Purdue at No. 2. With Saturday's news of Robbie Hummel's devastating retorn ACL, Katz has issued an updated version:

1. Duke: No reason to move the Blue Devils. Kyle Singler and Nolan Smith had tremendous summers working out with the USA Basketball select team. The buzz around newcomer Kyrie Irving is just as high. The karma is all good in Durham with Mike Krzyzewski winning a gold medal at the FIBA World Championship in Turkey and the Blue Devils getting a commitment from one of the best players in the 2011 class in Austin Rivers.

2. Michigan State: The Spartans did dump Chris Allen, an indication that the differences between Allen and Tom Izzo were too wide to overcome. But Izzo is feeling quite good about the continued recovery of Kalin Lucas from an Achilles injury. Lucas will be treated carefully in practice over the next month as the Spartans see how much he can push himself. But Izzo is confident Delvon Roe is as healthy as he's been at MSU and fully expects Durrell Summers to be a star and Draymond Green to be a vocal leader.

3. Pittsburgh: The Panthers don't have the star power of the aforementioned top three. But this Panthers team is like an old-school Big East team that has experienced players who have been together and found roles. The summer trip to Ireland provided more positive bonding time for Jamie Dixon's crew as it takes on the role of Big East favorite. There were no flaws this summer, making it more palatable to move the Panthers up a few spots.

4. Kansas State: The Wildcats continue to have a positive vibe from their near brush with a Final Four berth. Kansas State returns Jacob Pullen and an expectation that returnees like Curtis Kelly and Jamar Samuels will continue to blossom. Clearly the rest of the Big 12 believes in the Wildcats, as well, since they were picked to win the league for the first time.

5. Ohio State: The Buckeyes have one of the top freshmen in the country in big man Jared Sullinger. Sure, they lost Evan Turner, but the rest of the wings return and the buzz on the Buckeyes remains that this team was more than Turner a year ago. If players like William Buford, David Lighty and Jon Diebler can handle the responsibility, the Bucks should be a national contender.

6. Kansas: Moving the Jayhawks up to No. 7 is clearly predicated on Josh Selby being eligible for the majority of the season. KU is waiting for Selby to get his academic clearance from the Eligibility Center. He can practice while this is pending, but Kansas needs him out on the court during the real stuff. There is still plenty of talent in Lawrence -- led by Marcus Morris, who coach Bill Self is convinced will be a star -- but Selby is the key for the Jayhawks to be top-10 good.

7. Villanova: The Wildcats didn't rely on Scottie Reynolds in his last few games as much and they survived. Reynolds' eligibility expired and Corey Fisher is the next one to pick up the mantel. Jay Wright had another solid offseason, coaching the USA Basketball select team. There is an expectation now that Wright's teams won't dip. Like Pitt, Villanova is considered a regular near the top of the league on a yearly basis.

8. Gonzaga: The Zags had quite a summer with Elias Harris, Kelly Olynyk and Robert Sacre all playing for their respective national teams. Gonzaga put together arguably the toughest nonconference schedule in the country, too. If Demetri Goodson and Steven Gray can elevate their game as lead guards after the departure of Matt Bouldin, the Zags will be deserving of a top-10 ranking.

9. Florida: The Gators return all five starters from last season's No. 10 seed in the NCAA tournament. But the addition of Patric Young is surely going to bolster this squad. Young won gold for the USA junior national team this summer and proved to be an invaluable member of that squad. His tenacity, hustle plays and overall team focus means he could be a difference-maker for Florida this season.

10. Syracuse: The Orange move up six spots from the May poll in large part because coach Jim Boeheim is almost never wrong about evaluating and projecting his team's talent. Most of the time he hits on the major contributors and Boeheim said Kris Joseph is ready to be a star. He also expects big man Fab Melo to have a monster season, notably on the defensive end where he can block shots and grab rebounds. While it's hard to see yet where and how much C.J. Fair and Dion Waiters will play, they have already impressed, meaning the freshman class will make this team even deeper.

11. Kentucky: If Enes Kanter's eligibility was a certainty, the Wildcats would move up into the top 10. His amateurism eligibility decision is still to be determined. But what can be stated is Kentucky showed on a trip to Canada that the returning players are up for the challenge of a new role. Darius Miller and DeAndre Liggins should flourish as John Calipari plays more of his dribble-drive-motion offense. Newcomers like point guard Brandon Knight, Doron Lamb, Terrence Jones and Stacey Poole are all ready to make major contributions.

12. Missouri: The Tigers move up a notch, even without newcomer Tony Mitchell, whose eligibility is in question and in a best-case scenario wouldn't be available until the Big 12 schedule starts. But Mike Anderson can't play the role of being underappreciated anymore. Missouri returns Kim English, a healthy Justin Safford, Marcus Denmon and adds a recruiting class that needs to get more love. Anderson is pushing the significance of point guard Phil Pressey and power forward Ricardo Ratliffe. If both are as impactful as projected, Mizzou may be a league title contender.

13. Illinois: My colleague Doug Gottlieb tabbed the Illini to win the Big Ten. I'm not going that far with Purdue, Michigan State and Ohio State to contend with. But Illinois has no excuse if this is not an NCAA season at the very least. Bruce Weber can't say enough about how much incoming freshman Jereme Richmond will mean to this team. Add him to an already talented roster that includes Mike Davis, Mike Tisdale, D.J. Richardson and returning lead guard Demetri McCamey and the Illini have their best chance since 2005 to challenge for a conference title.

14. North Carolina: Losing the Wear twins and senior Will Graves, the team's top 3-point threat, meant the Tar Heels had to drop a few slots. The talent is in place up front with the return of John Henson and Tyler Zeller and the addition of the top freshman in the country in Harrison Barnes. But the guard play is still a work in progress and an unknown with erratic Larry Drew II and the still-inexperienced Dexter Strickland and Leslie McDonald being joined by newcomers Reggie Bullock and Kendall Marshall.

15. Memphis: The Tigers did get Will Barton eligible after there were questions earlier in the summer once he missed the team's trip to the Bahamas. But all is good now. The Tigers certainly have the talent to be projected higher, but remember they didn't make the NCAAs last season and are leaning heavily on newcomers like Barton, Joe Jackson and Tarik Black. If the Tigers are to be worthy of the top 10, then returnees like Wesley Witherspoon and Will Coleman will have to continue their improvement.

16. Baylor: This is by far the biggest drop in my poll from May to October. The Bears were probably too high in that original poll. Losing Ekpe Udoh and Tweety Carter was significant and maybe I was putting too much emphasis on newcomer Perry Jones. But the reason for this drop is LaceDarius Dunn. He is currently suspended from game competition, but was just reinstated to the team to practice and attend class after allegations that he broke his girlfriend's jaw. But the uncertainty of Dunn's availability casts major doubt on whether the Bears can be a serious contender in the Big 12.

17. Washington: Like Jay Wright, there was positive karma with Lorenzo Romar sharing the coaching duties in Las Vegas for the USA Basketball select team. And the guard play is extremely solid with the return of Isaiah Thomas, Venoy Overton and Abdul Gaddy, wings Justin Holiday and newcomers led by Terrence Ross. Losing Quincy Pondexter shouldn't be underplayed, though. We'll know early enough about the Huskies when they go to the Maui Invitational with a possible semifinal matchup against Kentucky.

18. Butler: Shelvin Mack had a sensational summer and the buzz continues to build that he's one of the top guards in the country. Mack played on the USA select team and the more confident he becomes, the better chance Butler has of being back in the mix for a deep March run again. Sure, losing Gordon Hayward early to the NBA is hard to take for this group, but if Ronald Nored is healthy enough to be as much of a scorer as he was a defender and Matt Howard adds even more productivity and stays out of foul trouble, the Bulldogs won't disappoint.

19. Georgetown: The Hoyas return one of the best backcourts in the Big East with Austin Freeman, Chris Wright and Jason Clark. If Julian Vaughn, Hollis Thompson and newcomers Nate Lubick and Moses Abraham can help offset the loss of Greg Monroe, Georgetown will be in the chase in the Big East. The Hoyas put themselves in position early with another tough slate of nonconference games (going to Old Dominion, Temple and Memphis, to Kansas City to play Missouri, and adding a home game against always-tough Utah State) to gauge where this team will be in January.

20. Tennessee: I probably had the Vols slightly too high in May and the NCAA investigation swirling around the program doesn't help, let alone the self-imposed sanctions against the entire coaching staff that have left a cloud over the season. It shouldn't affect the on-court performance of the players, but it will certainly be a distraction for the coaches as they have to deal with questions throughout the fall. Tennessee still has one of the top newcomers in guard Tobias Harris, and if Scotty Hopson can make shots in bunches, the Vols should still finish in the top three in the loaded SEC East.

21. San Diego State: The Aztecs have quietly gone through the summer with their roster intact, led by one of the more underrated forwards in the country in Kawhi Leonard. Malcolm Thomas is another stud for coach Steve Fisher. If the point guard situation gets settled, the Aztecs should be a top-25 squad. San Diego State challenged itself with five straight games away from home to open the season, including going to Gonzaga before heading off to three games in Oxford, Ohio, as part of the CBE Classic. If the Aztecs survive that stretch, they'll be in a solid position to enter the MWC season as the favorite, fending off BYU, New Mexico and UNLV.

22. Minnesota: The Gophers got two players back that would have certainly helped in March. Lead guard Al Nolen, who became academically ineligible in February last season, is good to go, as is forward Trevor Mbakwe, who sat out last season pending an assault case. Mbakwe is back in the good graces at the school, which stood by him during the case. The Gophers went to Canada in August and returned an even more determined lot. Don't sleep on this squad, especially in the Puerto Rico Tip-Off Classic. Nolen, Mbakwe, Devoe Joseph, Blake Hoffarber, Ralph Sampson III and Rodney Williams are all capable of leading the Gophers to a tournament win and into the top 25.

23. Purdue: On Friday, I ranked Purdue No. 2 and wrote that "the Boilermakers haven't had a single hiccup during the offseason." Less than 24 hours later, Robbie Hummel retore his right ACL during the team's first full practice. The loss can't be overstated. The Boilers still have a pair of All-Big Ten players in JaJuan Johnson and E'Twaun Moore and are still very much an NCAA tournament team, but it's hard to foresee this being a Final Four contender without Hummel.

24. Temple: The Owls got pushed down a peg by my newfound belief in Minnesota. Temple is still my pick to win the A-10 with the return of Lavoy Allen and guard Juan Fernandez. The Owls once again have a monster schedule that should tell us plenty by January, with an opener against Seton Hall, quality games in the Old Spice Classic in Orlando, playing Maryland in D.C., hosting Georgetown and going to Villanova. The Owls go to Duke, too, but that's not until late February. Oh, and of course, this team has one of the top coaches in the game in Fran Dunphy.

25. Georgia: I was bullish on the Bulldogs in May and I haven't dropped off in October with the return of Trey Thompkins and Travis Leslie, two of the top talents in the SEC. Georgia also adds Tennessee State transfer Gerald Robinson, who should open up some scoring on the perimeter. UGA will certainly be pushed in an SEC East that could produce up to five NCAA tourney teams, but the Bulldogs have some summer buzz and momentum heading into that Old Spice Classic tournament in Orlando, especially with an opener against Notre Dame.

Who got pushed out of the poll?
Virginia Tech: The Hokies were No. 22 in my May poll, but they lost one of their key rotation players in J.T. Thompson to a knee injury. Of course, the return of Malcolm Delaney means they will be in the hunt for a top-two finish in the ACC and an NCAA berth. But the Hokies weren't an NCAA team last season and losing a key player pushed them down a few spots for now.

A dozen more to watch (in alphabetical order): BYU, Florida State, New Mexico, Texas, UNLV, Utah State, Vanderbilt, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Wichita State, Wisconsin, Xavier

With the official start of practice Friday night, it feels like a good time to revisit my preseason top 25, which hasn't been touched since the final underclassman decisions were made in mid-May.

Not much has changed near the top. Duke is still No. 1, and will be in the majority of long-standing polls in the mainstream media and fledgling ones across the blogosphere.

But these Blue Devils aren't the 2009 Tar Heels. Duke is unquestionably the national favorite, but it's hardly an intimidating force. The schedule will favor the Devils in every game they play, but if they were to get beat by Kansas State or Gonzaga in Kansas City or by Michigan State at Cameron, or by Butler in New Jersey, no one would stop and consider it a tectonic shift in the season.

As for the rest of the poll, the pair of Big Ten teams at No. 2 (Purdue) and No. 3 (Michigan State) has not moved. But eligibility issues and suspensions over the past five months have forced some changes elsewhere in my top 25. Summer success, injuries and a re-evaluation of some teams has also caused some alterations.

So here is my new poll in advance of the season:

1. Duke: No reason to move the Blue Devils. Kyle Singler and Nolan Smith had tremendous summers working out with the USA Basketball select team. The buzz around newcomer Kyrie Irving is just as high. The karma is all good in Durham with Mike Krzyzewski winning a gold medal at the FIBA World Championship in Turkey and the Blue Devils getting a commitment from one of the best players in the 2011 class in Austin Rivers.

2. Purdue: The Boilermakers haven't had a single hiccup during the offseason. They have been quiet, which is just fine for a team that could be Duke's toughest challenge. Robbie Hummel continues to be on schedule to play this season after suffering an ACL tear in February. JaJuan Johnson and E'Twaun Moore join Hummel and offer Purdue the treat of three seniors who are all-Big Ten players. This team is a prime candidate for a spot in Houston.

3. Michigan State: The Spartans did dump Chris Allen, an indication that the differences between Allen and Tom Izzo were too wide to overcome. But Izzo is feeling quite good about the continued recovery of Kalin Lucas from an Achilles injury. Lucas will be treated carefully in practice over the next month as the Spartans see how much he can push himself. But Izzo is confident Delvon Roe is as healthy as he's been at MSU and fully expects Durrell Summers to be a star and Draymond Green to be a vocal leader.

4. Pittsburgh: The Panthers don't have the star power of the aforementioned top three. But this Panthers team is like an old-school Big East team that has experienced players who have been together and found roles. The summer trip to Ireland provided more positive bonding time for Jamie Dixon's crew as it takes on the role of Big East favorite. There were no flaws this summer, making it more palatable to move the Panthers up a few spots.

5. Kansas State: The Wildcats continue to have a positive vibe from their near brush with a Final Four berth. Kansas State returns Jacob Pullen and an expectation that returnees like Curtis Kelly and Jamar Samuels will continue to blossom. Clearly the rest of the Big 12 believes in the Wildcats, as well, since they were picked to win the league for the first time.

6. Ohio State: The Buckeyes have one of the top freshmen in the country in big man Jared Sullinger. Sure, they lost Evan Turner, but the rest of the wings return and the buzz on the Buckeyes remains that this team was more than Turner a year ago. If players like William Buford, David Lighty and Jon Diebler can handle the responsibility, the Bucks should be a national contender.

7. Kansas: Moving the Jayhawks up to No. 7 is clearly predicated on Josh Selby being eligible for the majority of the season. KU is waiting for Selby to get his academic clearance from the Eligibility Center. He can practice while this is pending, but Kansas needs him out on the court during the real stuff. There is still plenty of talent in Lawrence -- led by Marcus Morris, who coach Bill Self is convinced will be a star -- but Selby is the key for the Jayhawks to be top-10 good.

8. Villanova: The Wildcats didn't rely on Scottie Reynolds in his last few games as much and they survived. Reynolds' eligibility expired and Corey Fisher is the next one to pick up the mantel. Jay Wright had another solid offseason, coaching the USA Basketball select team. There is an expectation now that Wright's teams won't dip. Like Pitt, Villanova is considered a regular near the top of the league on a yearly basis.

9. Gonzaga: The Zags had quite a summer with Elias Harris, Kelly Olynyk and Robert Sacre all playing for their respective national teams. Gonzaga put together arguably the toughest nonconference schedule in the country, too. If Demetri Goodson and Steven Gray can elevate their game as lead guards after the departure of Matt Bouldin, the Zags will be deserving of a top-10 ranking.

10. Florida: The Gators return all five starters from last season's No. 10 seed in the NCAA tournament. But the addition of Patric Young is surely going to bolster this squad. Young won gold for the USA junior national team this summer and proved to be an invaluable member of that squad. His tenacity, hustle plays and overall team focus means he could be a difference-maker for Florida this season.

11. Syracuse: The Orange move up six spots from the May poll in large part because coach Jim Boeheim is almost never wrong about evaluating and projecting his team's talent. Most of the time he hits on the major contributors and Boeheim said Kris Joseph is ready to be a star. He also expects big man Fab Melo to have a monster season, notably on the defensive end where he can block shots and grab rebounds. While it's hard to see yet where and how much C.J. Fair and Dion Waiters will play, they have already impressed, meaning the freshman class will make this team even deeper.

12. Kentucky: If Enes Kanter's eligibility was a certainty, the Wildcats would move up into the top 10. His amateurism eligibility decision is still to be determined. But what can be stated is Kentucky showed on a trip to Canada that the returning players are up for the challenge of a new role. Darius Miller and DeAndre Liggins should flourish as John Calipari plays more of his dribble-drive-motion offense. Newcomers like point guard Brandon Knight, Doron Lamb, Terrence Jones and Stacey Poole are all ready to make major contributions.

13. Missouri: The Tigers move up a notch, even without newcomer Tony Mitchell, whose eligibility is in question and in a best-case scenario wouldn't be available until the Big 12 schedule starts. But Mike Anderson can't play the role of being underappreciated anymore. Missouri returns Kim English, a healthy Justin Safford, Marcus Denmon and adds a recruiting class that needs to get more love. Anderson is pushing the significance of point guard Phil Pressey and power forward Ricardo Ratliffe. If both are as impactful as projected, Mizzou may be a league title contender.

14. Illinois: My colleague Doug Gottlieb tabbed the Illini to win the Big Ten. I'm not going that far with Purdue, Michigan State and Ohio State to contend with. But Illinois has no excuse if this is not an NCAA season at the very least. Bruce Weber can't say enough about how much incoming freshman Jereme Richmond will mean to this team. Add him to an already talented roster that includes Mike Davis, Mike Tisdale, D.J. Richardson and returning lead guard Demetri McCamey and the Illini have their best chance since 2005 to challenge for a conference title.

15. North Carolina: Losing the Wear twins and senior Will Graves, the team's top 3-point threat, meant the Tar Heels had to drop a few slots. The talent is in place up front with the return of John Henson and Tyler Zeller and the addition of the top freshman in the country in Harrison Barnes. But the guard play is still a work in progress and an unknown with erratic Larry Drew II and the still-inexperienced Dexter Strickland and Leslie McDonald being joined by newcomers Reggie Bullock and Kendall Marshall.

16. Memphis: The Tigers did get Will Barton eligible after there were questions earlier in the summer once he missed the team's trip to the Bahamas. But all is good now. The Tigers certainly have the talent to be projected higher, but remember they didn't make the NCAAs last season and are leaning heavily on newcomers like Barton, Joe Jackson and Tarik Black. If the Tigers are to be worthy of the top 10, then returnees like Wesley Witherspoon and Will Coleman will have to continue their improvement.

17. Baylor: This is by far the biggest drop in my poll from May to October. The Bears were probably too high in that original poll. Losing Ekpe Udoh and Tweety Carter was significant and maybe I was putting too much emphasis on newcomer Perry Jones. But the reason for this drop is LaceDarius Dunn. He is currently suspended from game competition, but was just reinstated to the team to practice and attend class after allegations that he broke his girlfriend's jaw. But the uncertainty of Dunn's availability casts major doubt on whether the Bears can be a serious contender in the Big 12.

18. Washington: Like Jay Wright, there was positive karma with Lorenzo Romar sharing the coaching duties in Las Vegas for the USA Basketball select team. And the guard play is extremely solid with the return of Isaiah Thomas, Venoy Overton and Abdul Gaddy, wings Justin Holiday and newcomers led by Terrence Ross. Losing Quincy Pondexter shouldn't be underplayed, though. We'll know early enough about the Huskies when they go to the Maui Invitational with a possible semifinal matchup against Kentucky.

19. Butler: Shelvin Mack had a sensational summer and the buzz continues to build that he's one of the top guards in the country. Mack played on the USA select team and the more confident he becomes, the better chance Butler has of being back in the mix for a deep March run again. Sure, losing Gordon Hayward early to the NBA is hard to take for this group, but if Ronald Nored is healthy enough to be as much of a scorer as he was a defender and Matt Howard adds even more productivity and stays out of foul trouble, the Bulldogs won't disappoint.

20. Georgetown: The Hoyas return one of the best backcourts in the Big East with Austin Freeman, Chris Wright and Jason Clark. If Julian Vaughn, Hollis Thompson and newcomers Nate Lubick and Moses Abraham can help offset the loss of Greg Monroe, Georgetown will be in the chase in the Big East. The Hoyas put themselves in position early with another tough slate of nonconference games (going to Old Dominion, Temple and Memphis, to Kansas City to play Missouri, and adding a home game against always-tough Utah State) to gauge where this team will be in January.

21. Tennessee: I probably had the Vols slightly too high in May and the NCAA investigation swirling around the program doesn't help, let alone the self-imposed sanctions against the entire coaching staff that have left a cloud over the season. It shouldn't affect the on-court performance of the players, but it will certainly be a distraction for the coaches as they have to deal with questions throughout the fall. Tennessee still has one of the top newcomers in guard Tobias Harris, and if Scotty Hopson can make shots in bunches, the Vols should still finish in the top three in the loaded SEC East.

22. San Diego State: The Aztecs have quietly gone through the summer with their roster intact, led by one of the more underrated forwards in the country in Kawhi Leonard. Malcolm Thomas is another stud for coach Steve Fisher. If the point guard situation gets settled, the Aztecs should be a top-25 squad. San Diego State challenged itself with five straight games away from home to open the season, including going to Gonzaga before heading off to three games in Oxford, Ohio, as part of the CBE Classic. If the Aztecs survive that stretch, they'll be in a solid position to enter the MWC season as the favorite, fending off BYU, New Mexico and UNLV.

23. Minnesota: The Gophers got two players back that would have certainly helped in March. Lead guard Al Nolen, who became academically ineligible in February last season, is good to go, as is forward Trevor Mbakwe, who sat out last season pending an assault case. Mbakwe is back in the good graces at the school, which stood by him during the case. The Gophers went to Canada in August and returned an even more determined lot. Don't sleep on this squad, especially in the Puerto Rico Tip-Off Classic. Nolen, Mbakwe, Devoe Joseph, Blake Hoffarber, Ralph Sampson III and Rodney Williams are all capable of leading the Gophers to a tournament win and into the top 25.

24. Temple: The Owls got pushed down a peg by my newfound belief in Minnesota. Temple is still my pick to win the A-10 with the return of Lavoy Allen and guard Juan Fernandez. The Owls once again have a monster schedule that should tell us plenty by January, with an opener against Seton Hall, quality games in the Old Spice Classic in Orlando, playing Maryland in D.C., hosting Georgetown and going to Villanova. The Owls go to Duke, too, but that's not until late February. Oh, and of course, this team has one of the top coaches in the game in Fran Dunphy.

25. Georgia: I was bullish on the Bulldogs in May and I haven't dropped off in October with the return of Trey Thompkins and Travis Leslie, two of the top talents in the SEC. Georgia also adds Tennessee State transfer Gerald Robinson, who should open up some scoring on the perimeter. UGA will certainly be pushed in an SEC East that could produce up to five NCAA tourney teams, but the Bulldogs have some summer buzz and momentum heading into that Old Spice Classic tournament in Orlando, especially with an opener against Notre Dame.

Who got pushed out of the poll?
Virginia Tech: The Hokies were No. 22 in my May poll, but they lost one of their key rotation players in J.T. Thompson to a knee injury. Of course, the return of Malcolm Delaney means they will be in the hunt for a top-two finish in the ACC and an NCAA berth. But the Hokies weren't an NCAA team last season and losing a key player pushed them down a few spots for now.

A dozen more to watch (in alphabetical order): BYU, Florida State, New Mexico, Texas, UNLV, Utah State, Vanderbilt, Virginia Tech, West Virginia, Wichita State, Wisconsin, Xavier