Committee seeks more transparency

Updated: March 12, 2012, 12:35 AM ET
ESPN.com news services

INDIANAPOLIS -- The NCAA's attempt to be more transparent about its tournament selection process proved one thing Sunday: It's still subjective.

Some schools, such as Iona, apparently met the eye test this season. Others, such as Washington and Seton Hall, did not.

"In general they were a very, very good team during the course of the year," committee vice chairman Mike Bobinski said of Iona during an hour-long show on TruTV. "I saw them play a number of times myself, and I think they're going to hold up very well in the tourney."

The truth is Iona's RPI ranking (47) was better than Washington (70), Drexel (66) or the other five teams on the committee's list of those left out.

Sunday's show "Hardcore Brackets" was intended to give fans a more in-depth look into how the 10 committee members determine the 68-team bracket that will be filled out by millions of people over the next several days.

For the first time, the committee released the seeding, from 1 to 68. It also listed the first six teams left out: Drexel, Miami, Mississippi State, Nevada, Oral Roberts and Seton Hall.

All it really did, though, was raise more questions and create a larger debate as it always does.

Committee chairman Jeff Hathaway acknowledged yet again during the show that one key factor the committee uses is how teams schedule. Critics could look at Iona's schedule ranking of 161 and Washington's rank (97) and wonder how the committee could make such an argument.

But the rankings aren't the sole arbiter in this process.

"You have to be aggressive in the (nonconference) scheduling. People are doing that," Hathaway said. "You look at Michigan State and they are No. 1 in strength of schedule. A lot of people are reaching out and doing that. Keep in mind, coaches have to do what's best for their program given the talent they have."

It can hurt anyone. Hathaway noted that Missouri, the Big 12 tourney champ, was not in serious contention for a No. 1 seed because of a weaker nonconference schedule. Kansas, the regular-season league champ, was because it played teams like Duke, Kentucky and Ohio State before starting league play.

The easiest way to simplify the process might be establishing a standard protocol of what it takes to get in.

But even Hathaway noted it wouldn't eliminate the subjectivity of the evaluations.

"I wish it was that easy. As you know there's only 37 at-large slots and if we set that kind of criteria, a lot of people could do that and then we'd have to look at who did it the best," Hathaway said. "So I don't think it's quite that easy. It's not as cut-and-dry as that, and again, 10 people look at the data in 10 different ways and they're also watching all those games on TV and in person."

Information from The Associated Press was used in this report.