| ESPN Network: ESPN | NBA.com | NHL.com | ABC | Radio | EXPN | Insider | Shop | Fantasy |
![]() |
| Friday, August 31 Updated: September 7, 2:02 PM ET True superstars can do it all By Joe Morgan Special to ESPN.com |
||||||||||||||
|
At last month's players-only Hall of Fame dinner, one of the greatest players who ever lived made a statement that it is becoming too easy for players to get into the Hall of Fame because more players are being considered "superstars." And he is right; the term "superstar" is used too loosely now to describe great players.
In the past a superstar was an everyday player who could hit, hit for power, run, field and throw. Plus, he had to be an intelligent player, someone who knew how to play the game. Now, players are called superstars if they can only do one or two things well. That's the problem. Hitting 50 home runs or stealing 100 bases doesn't make a player a superstar. He may be a great hitter, baserunner or fielder. Being excellent in one or two areas of the game makes someone a star, but not a superstar. Teams should never have to pinch-run, pinch-hit or play defense for a superstar. He has to be a complete player, one who can do everything on the field. No one ever had to replace Willie Mays, Hank Aaron or Roberto Clemente late in the game. Their teams just let them play. A superstar player must meet the following qualifications, applying to all positions but pitcher:
Examples of players who meet the superstar criteria are Alex Rodriguez as an infielder, Vladimir Guerrero as an outfielder and Ivan Rodriguez as a catcher. There is nothing they can't do on a baseball field. Although some players are having superstar seasons, their performance this season alone doesn't make them a superstar. The two best examples may be Bret Boone in the American League and Luis Gonzalez in the National League. Before they can be called true superstars, they must at least continue to play at the same all-around level beyond this season. A player who appears on the way to superstardom is Cardinals' rookie Albert Pujols, but he needs to sustain his level of excellence. There are several superstars in baseball, but just not as many as people think. Consider my superstar criteria and how it may apply to other major-league players. How do they stack up against superstars like A-Rod, Guerrero and Pudge at their positions? Who needs to come out for a pinch-runner because his team needs more speed on the bases? Who needs to be replaced by a pinch-hitter late in the game to drive in a critical run or face a tough relief pitcher? Who requires a defensive replacement in the eighth inning of a close game? Examine the major-league rosters and decide which players fit the superstar mold. Hall of Fame second baseman Joe Morgan is a baseball analyst for ESPN. |
| |||||||||||||
|
|