Dave Winfield, RF
Career: 1973-95, Padres, Yankees, others
Fun fact: Taken in MLB, NBA and NFL drafts
Winfield is your classic compiler -- an excellent player for a long time (3,110 career hits) who led the league in any category in only one season (118 RBIs in 1979).
That lack of dominance, plus a career .208 postseason average that made George Steinbrenner call him Mr. May, is why he's outside the 100.