Series: Game 3 of 3

Toronto won 2-1

Game 1: Friday, August 29
Game 2: Saturday, August 30
Game 3: Sunday, August 31

Blue Jays 4

(67-69, 38-33 away)

Indians 5

(61-76, 35-36 home)

    1:05 PM ET, August 31, 2003

    Progressive Field, Cleveland, Ohio 

    123456789 R H E
    TOR 001003000 4 6 2
    CLE 021000002 5 9 0

    W: D. Baez (1-7)

    L: J. Kershner (0-3)

    Catalanotto's errant throw plates winning runs

    CLEVELAND (AP) -- The Toronto Blue Jays made a few defensive replacements in the ninth inning Sunday.

    The moves paid off immediately -- for the Cleveland Indians.

    Throwing errors by catcher Kevin Cash and first baseman Frank Catalanotto allowed two runs to score, helping the Indians win 5-4 and avoid a three-game sweep.

    "As a defensive replacement, you want to go in and not be seen," Cash said. "Today, obviously, I was seen a little bit."

    With the Indians down 4-3, Tim Laker led off the ninth with a single. Jhonny Peralta laid down a bunt two feet in front of home plate that Cash threw into center field to put runners at second and third.

    Pinch-hitter Matt Lawton hit a grounder to first that Catalanotto charged and threw past Cash, letting pinch-runner Angel Santos and Peralta score.

    Catalanotto pinch-hit in the ninth for starting catcher Tom Wilson, then stayed in to play first base, replacing Josh Phelps. Cash replaced Wilson.

    Catalanotto, who has started only two games at first this season, said he simply missed his target.

    "I'm a big league player. I have to make those plays," he said. "We should have won the game. It's tough to be the reason when you lose."

    Danys Baez (1-7) pitched an inning of scoreless relief for his first win in exactly a year.

    Jason Kershner (0-3) gave up a hit and two unearned runs. He retired one batter in the eighth.

    Blue Jays manager Carlos Tosca refused to second-guess his ninth-inning moves.

    "If I had to do it all over again, I'd do it the same way," Tosca said. "Baez is real tough on right-handed hitters, so I wanted to give Catalanotto a chance to swing the bat."

    Catalanotto singled off Baez, but was stranded at second.

    Tosca said Cash has played well behind the plate and that Catalanotto, primarily an outfielder, is Toronto's best first baseman after Carlos Delgado.

    "Obviously, it's a tough way to lose a game," Tosca said. "We haven't lost too many by throwing the ball around. Both guys had more time than they probably realized. They got a little too excited and tried to do too much."

    The Blue Jays took a 4-3 lead on Phelps' two-run homer. His 15th of the season capped a three-run sixth inning that started with singles by Reed Johnson and Mike Bordick. Delgado also had an RBI in the inning on a sacrifice fly.

    Alex Escobar hit a solo home run for Cleveland and Brandon Phillips got his first hit and RBI since he was recalled Thursday from Triple-A Buffalo.

    Indians manager Eric Wedge said he wasn't pleased with the way his team played until the ninth.

    "There was some bad baseball played out there off and on today," Wedge said.

    Cleveland starter Billy Traber was pulled when he hit Bobby Kielty with a pitch after the homer by Phelps.

    Toronto starter Mark Hendrickson went 4 1-3 innings, giving up three runs on seven hits and two walks. It was the eighth time Hendrickson has not made it out of the fifth inning.

    Pete Walker pitched 3 1-3 scoreless innings of relief for the Blue Jays. He allowed just a hit and a walk.

    Escobar hit his second homer of the season in the third, a line shot that a fan caught leaning over the railing of the 19-foot high wall in left field.

    Cleveland took an early lead when Phillips grounded out in the second. Coco Crisp followed with an RBI single to put the Indians up 2-0.

    Chris Woodward opened the third with a ground-rule double that hit the right-field line for Toronto's first hit. Mike Bordick drove Woodward home with a two-out double.

    Game notes

    Cleveland SS Omar Vizquel was a late scratch from the lineup because of soreness in his right knee. ... The Blue Jays had won five straight at Jacobs Field. ... Crisp had two singles and two steals. He was thrown out on his third stolen-base attempt. ... The Blue Jays have not won a one-run game since June 27 and are 10-20 in one-run games.

    Copyright by STATS LLC and The Associated Press