Colts, Redskins should be nervous
If history is a guide, odds are against both Luck and RG3 becoming great QBs
Barring unforeseen circumstances, Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III will be the first two players selected in the 2012 draft, becoming the fifth quarterback pair to go first and second overall since the NFL and AFL combined drafts in 1967.
In the past 45 drafts, two quarterbacks went in the top 10 20 times, and three quarterbacks went in the top 10 three times. Two in the top 10 happened six times from 1967 to 1982, but starting with the quarterback-heavy 1983 draft -- the only draft to produce three Hall of Fame quarterbacks in the first round (John Elway, Jim Kelly and Dan Marino) -- multiple quarterbacks have gone in the first 10 picks 14 times.
History suggests that either the Colts or Redskins are going to end up regretting their choice. History further suggests it won't be the Colts.
Success has generally been elusive for one of the two quarterbacks selected in the top 10. A simple way to look at success is games started, as it would stand to reason that getting starts deep into a career would indicate a quarterback was doing something right.
Using 80 starts as a benchmark, the equivalent of five full seasons, only three times since 1967 have both quarterbacks drafted in the top 10 reached 80 starts. Eighteen of the 20 tandems have been in the NFL long enough to reach 80 starts, but only one of the tandems short of having both get to 80 is active, with Byron Leftwich 31 starts short of joining Carson Palmer. Leftwich has been a backup since leaving Jacksonville after the 2006 season.
Two Quarterbacks Drafted In Top 10, 1967-2011
|Year||First Taken||Second Taken||Reached 80 GS|
|2011*||Cam Newton, 1st||Jake Locker, 8th||N/A|
|2009||Matthew Stafford, 1st||Mark Sanchez, 5th||N/A|
|2006||Vince Young, 3rd||Matt Leinart, 10th||Neither|
|2004||Eli Manning, 1st||Philip Rivers, 4th||Both|
|2003||Carson Palmer, 1st||Byron Leftwich, 7th||Palmer|
|2002||David Carr, 1st||Joey Harrington, 3rd||Neither|
|1999*||Tim Couch, 1st||Donovan McNabb, 2nd||McNabb|
|1998||Peyton Manning, 1st||Ryan Leaf, 2nd||Manning|
|1995||Steve McNair, 3rd||Kerry Collins, 5th||Both|
|1994||Heath Shuler, 3rd||Trent Dilfer, 6th||Dilfer|
|1993||Drew Bledsoe, 1st||Rick Mirer, 2nd||Bledsoe|
|1990||Jeff George, 1st||Andrew Ware, 7th||George|
|1987||Vinny Testaverde, 1st||Kelly Stouffer, 6th||Testaverde|
|1983||John Elway, 1st||Todd Blackledge, 7th||Elway|
|1982||Art Schlichter, 4th||Jim McMahon, 5th||McMahon|
|1979||Jack Thompson, 3rd||Phil Simms, 7th||Simms|
|1971*||Jim Plunkett, 1st||Archie Manning, 2nd||Both|
|1970||Terry Bradshaw, 1st||Mike Phipps, 3rd||Bradshaw|
|1969||Greg Cook, 5th||Marty Domres, 9th||Neither|
|1967||Steve Spurrier, 3rd||Bob Griese, 4th||Griese|
|*Three quarterbacks taken within top 10|
Recent mock drafts suggest Texas A&M quarterback Ryan Tannehill also will be selected in the top 10. Although a small sample, the only instances of a third quarterback taken in the top 10 have produced unflattering results: Dan Pastorini in 1971 (117 GS, negative-58 TD-INT differential), Akili Smith in 1999 (17 GS, five career TD passes) and Blaine Gabbert in 2011 (posted 21.1 Total QBR in rookie season, worst among qualified quarterbacks).
Drew Bledsoe (first) made 125 more starts than Rick Mirer (second), Peyton Manning (first) has 187 starts more than Ryan Leaf (second), and Donovan McNabb (second) got 102 more than Tim Couch (first).
So does being the first or second off the board matter?
Initially, the second quarterback in the top 10 outperformed the first one. From 1967-82, Bob Griese, Phil Simms and Jim McMahon won Super Bowls and, along with Archie Manning, had 3,000-yard passing seasons. All four eclipsed 80 career starts.
First Two QBs Taken in Top 10, 1967-1982
|First QB Taken||Second QB Taken|
Since 1983, however, the dynamic has shifted. Discounting quarterbacks taken in the past four seasons, only four of the second quarterbacks off the board reached the 80-start benchmark. With the same number of quarterbacks in more than twice as many attempts, that means it has become more difficult to find a franchise guy in the top 10 once the first is taken.
Statistically, the difference between the first and second quarterbacks is great. The first quarterbacks have accumulated 170,000 passing yards and 1,100 touchdowns more than the second quarterbacks.
First Two QBs Taken in Top 10, 1983-2011
|First QB Taken||Second QB Taken|
Following a quarterback who was taken first overall also factors into the equation of success for multiple top-10 quarterbacks.
Thirteen quarterbacks had to follow a first overall selection in the top 10. The 13 combined for a TD-Int differential of plus-48 and just three eclipsed 80 starts (Philip Rivers, McNabb and Archie Manning), with two yet to play enough games (Mark Sanchez and Jake Locker). Nine of the 11 who went first overall who could reach 80 did so, with the 13 first overall selections combining for a plus-462 TD-INT differential.
When the first of multiple quarterbacks in the top 10 isn't the first overall pick, the dynamic shifts. There have been seven instances of this happening since 1967, and in this scenario, the first quarterback selected reached 80 starts once, with the group combining for a minus-4 TD-INT differential. The quarterbacks following reached 80 starts five times and combined for a plus-40 TD-INT differential.
When there are two top quarterback prospects taken in the top 10, success, maybe not surprisingly, tends to favor the first one taken. Griffin certainly possesses the skills to buck the trends and equal, if not better, the success of Luck, though.
But if the evidence wasn't piling up enough against Griffin, here's one more tidbit that's working against him. Griffin would be the third Heisman winner to be the second quarterback taken in the top 10. The first two? Matt Leinart and Andre Ware, who have combined for 24 career starts.
MORE NFL HEADLINES
- Saints top Panthers to take NFC South lead
- Sources: Redskins' Hall tears Achilles again
- Judge rejects Hernandez trial venue change
- Cowboys hopeful as Romo doesn't practice
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
The NFL on ESPN.com