Smaller window for position battles
Because new CBA calls for fewer practices, coaches' jobs even more challenging
Timing is everything, and the current CBA will alter the ways teams handle position battles.
Under the new training-camp-lite CBA, coaches don't have the luxury of two-a-day practices. They have to give players a day off after five consecutive days of practice. That doesn't leave a lot of time to handle major battles at certain positions.
Do you have a query for John Clayton?
Click here to send a note to his mailbag.
Competition is great, but part of this year's training camp is getting that quarterback ready for the opener with fewer practices to get the offense to respond.
The Seahawks have only 12 practices before their first preseason game. The training camp portion of the preseason contains only 15 practices. There are only five more practices over the final two weeks of the preseason.
That's 20 practices and four preseason games. Having good competition at quarterback is one thing, but at some point, Carroll and other coaches around the league need to focus on getting that starting quarterback ready for the opener.
Normally, coaches like to name their starting quarterback after three preseason games. With the limits on practice time, coaches might name their starter after two weeks, giving the starter the third preseason game to work with the offense before sitting out the fourth preseason game to protect against injury.
But it's not out of the question for some coaches to use that starter in the fourth preseason game because his time is so limited with the rest of the starters. The risk of that, though, might not be smart.
In 2011, coaches found ways of getting their teams ready for the regular season without the benefit of an offseason program, earning their pay. The new system, though, will be equally challenging.
From the inbox
Q: With a potential suspension coming for Dez Bryant, a seemingly injury-prone Miles Austin and uncertainty everywhere else in the Dallas receiving corps, would the Cowboys be wise to try and pick up a veteran wide receiver before training camp begins?
Jeff in Tulsa, Okla.
A: The answer is yes but they don't have to move quickly. If Bryant is suspended, the Cowboys would be devastated at wide receiver. It's the same thing if Austin suffers an injury. They have only two legitimate wide receivers unless you believe totally in Kevin Ogletree. That said, I think they will be wide receiver shopping during camp. Laurent Robinson was the perfect No. 3 wide receiver, but he snagged more than $6 million a year from the Jaguars this offseason. The Cowboys need to find another Laurent Robinson.
Kurt in Minnesota wonders if the Bengals have done enough to improve above third place in the AFC North. I think they had a great draft, but I'm not sold they are ready to make that jump this year. Nick in Maine has questions about the Patriots' backup quarterback situation behind Tom Brady and the eventual long-term replacement. They believe in Brian Hoyer as a backup. They also have Ryan Mallett's strong arm developing behind him. That might never equal the value of Brady, but at least they have addressed the issue for now. Scott in Paramus, N.J., knows the departure of Mario Manningham created the need for a third receiver on the Giants to step up. I think that's where Rueben Randle comes into focus more so than Ramses Barden or Domenik Hixon. At least there are three options. With declining attendance in the NFL, Mark in Bossier City, La., would like to see teams lowering prices for families. Football has some of the best of the best making those business decisions. If they can't easily sell tickets to the rich, they will adjust their prices to fill the seats. Now that attendance has dropped for five straight years, teams will need to be more creative and flexible. Brendan in New Jersey, I do see Chad Ochocinco having a bounce-back year with the Dolphins. This is a good fit. They lack receivers and he gives them sure hands. He won't be at his Pro Bowl level, but I think he will put up respectable numbers. Bob in Auburn, Ala., can't figure out why the NFL doesn't have an Internet package similar to MLB.TV. It does: It's called DIRECTV broadband. Remember, the NFL has only a 16-game schedule. Baseball has a 162-game schedule, so it can sell its Internet packages at a lower price. Joe in York, Pa., is outraged with the price of preseason games. That problem won't be solved until Roger Goodell can talk the players into an 18-game schedule. Goodell agrees preseason games are a major issue. But the players don't want to play 18 regular-season games for fear of injury and the wear and tear on bodies. Rich in Salisbury, Md., has heard the arguments about whether or not the NFL should hire full-time officials. What he hasn't seen is whether the NFL would consider hiring the crew chief full time. Last season, that topic was on the table. The labor problems with the officials delayed any action in that regard. I think that will be an option in a couple of years.
Q: I'm telling you now you better jump on the Bears' bandwagon. If you think they were impressive at 7-3 after 10 games last season, wait until they are 9-1 or 10-0.
Byron in Decatur, Ill.
A: I'm already there. I have them making the playoffs as a wild card over the Detroit Lions because I think they had a better offseason than the Lions. They added more weapons on offense, and that will help. I'm not ready to put them over the Packers. The Packers have the deepest receiving corps in football and they have Aaron Rodgers. For the Bears, I'm all-in.
Q: I heard Amani Toomer say he believes Tony Romo is better than Eli Manning because of his numbers and his numbers are only slightly better than Eli's. But Romo plays at least eight games in a dome. Eli plays eight in the Meadowlands; could this be the difference? Could you somehow find what Eli's numbers are in a dome?
William in Lakewood, N.J.
A: After looking at the numbers, the dome factor might not be pronounced enough to show a difference. I still contend the difference is Manning has won eight playoff games in the two years he helped to take the Giants to two Super Bowl victories. Romo has one playoff win during his career. Since 2009, when the Cowboys started playing in a dome, Romo has completed 67.1 percent of 648 passes for an average of 266.85 yards per game. He has 40 touchdown passes and 14 interceptions in those 20 domed games. Manning averaged 367.3 yards a game at home over those three years, completing 61.8 percent of his passes. He threw 76 touchdown passes and 49 interceptions at home. In seven domed games for Manning over that stretch, he completed 62.5 percent of his passes for 275.71 yards a game. Romo completed 63.7 percent of his passes in road games and averaged 258.05 yards.
Q: I'm trying to thoroughly understand how the NFL salary cap works after the new CBA. I'm not exactly following everything with the rollover, adjustments and the ability to spend what seems to be in upwards of $20-plus million over the $120.6 million cap set for 2012.
Nick in Philadelphia
A: Simple explanation. Up until this year, any unspent salary-cap money went in the owners' pockets. There was no carryover. Starting this year, the team has the option to carry over unspent cap money from the previous season. The Eagles, for example, had $17.8 million of unspent cap money at the end of last season. They elected to carry it over to this year. It took their $120.6 million cap to $138.4 million. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers carried over $23.5 million and improved their cap to $144.1 million. Of course, if all that money is spent this year, there will be no carryover.
Q: What holes do you expect the Browns to address in next year's draft?
Jordan in Washington, D.C.
A: With the additions of Trent Richardson, Brandon Weeden and Josh Gordon, the Browns can switch over to defense in next year's draft. They may look at linebackers. They will continue to bulk up the defensive line. They might have to replace Sheldon Brown at corner, since he's 33. They do need Greg Little to step up this season to keep them out of the wide receiver market for another draft.
Q: Is there a way to get around the draft to effectively choose your own future?
James in New Orleans
A: No. I guess a player can sit out three years after his last year of college eligibility and see if he can get into the league that way, but that's a trap. The league is set up to use the draft as the entry into pro football. I guess a good player could play baseball for three years and then try to get into pro football, but what would those three years in a different sport do to improve his football bargaining clout? He'd be 25 or older and have been away from the game for three years, which would devalue his stock.
Q: With all the trouble that the Lions have had and now Cowboys receiver Dez Bryant yet again having issues, why doesn't the NFL say if you have a troubled past you have to clean that up and act like a man before you're allowed to be drafted?
Grant in Atlanta
A: That's a team's decision, not a league decision. If a player has a troubled past, many teams remove that name from their draft boards. But blocking a player with a troubled past from coming into the league until he cleans up his act would be discriminating. It would expose the league to a lawsuit.
Q: I'm old enough to recall a time when players took offseason jobs in insurance or car sales in order to make a reasonable wage for a year. It strikes me that today, with a salary cap in place, a player's personal greed debilitates his team from paying other players, potentially making that team less competitive. The Drew Brees situation comes to mind: a QB demanding more in salary than the accumulated salaries of his starting offensive mates. I'm all for being paid handsomely, but doesn't such a large salary have implications in retaining other players, key or not, and ultimately affect team strength as well as potentially ruffle feathers of teammates? Wouldn't some of these guys better serve their team's chances of winning -- and arguably their own personal success -- by taking a bit less?
Kurt in Traverse City, Mich.
A: Greed isn't necessarily good for a player in a team concept, but there are a few more dynamics to the equation. By Brees going to $20 million instead of $19 million, it moves the top price for quarterbacks to a higher level and helps the next franchise quarterback looking for a contract. Remember, Brees works with the NFL Players Association. Plus, his demands didn't destroy the Saints' payroll. He was even willing to accept lower cap numbers in the first few years of his contract than the team was offering. That extra room allows more players to stay together on the team. It's a business from the team's side but it's also a business from the player's side. As you would have to admit, it's now big business.
The NFL on ESPN.com