ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY  
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com
rpm.espn.com




Monday, September 23
Updated: January 12, 5:52 PM ET
Robin Miller's Mailbag
Robin Miller answers user mail
ESPN.com

Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers:




For some time now I've thought that NASCAR was more of a personality cult than auto racing. The last two years I've had the opportunity to mingle with a number of NASCAR fans at Indy and Chicagoland. I own several articles of clothing with IRL, IMS, Indy 500, and USGP logos on them. But I've yet to see anyone wearing NASCAR-related items that didn't feature a specific driver. Would you care to comment on how the different racing series have been marketed relative to their fan followings?

Jim Wallace
Wheaton, Ill.

Robin Miller: Plain and simple, NASCAR has kicked everybody's butt in marketing their drivers. NASCAR is all about heroes and keeping the same drivers, sponsors, car numbers and color schemes has also been very beneficial. The IRL has had more than 125 drivers in seven seasons so obviously it's a little tough to grow identity, while CART was always about the owners and not the drivers. NHRA does a decent job but John Force commands most of the attention (as well he should). F1 has fanatics, but the race fan cannot connect with any of the drivers because they're not allowed within 300 yards of them.




First I would like to say I look forward to your reports on RPM2Night every Wednesday. And I just have one question -- What do you think Max Papis will be driving in 2003?

Sandi Mack
Torrance, Calif.

Robin Miller: Max might end up in CART if Frank and Al Arciero field a car but he's also looking at IRL and sports cars. Thanks for watching.




Keep up the excellent work. My question is this: in the "old" days, some teams would enter a third car at select grands prix for a local "up and coming" local driver. With all Tony George's power, why has he not brokered such a deal for Sam Hornish Jr. (as IRL champ) to help sell tickets and give U.S. racing a shot in the arm. Nobody expects Hornish to compete for the win so there would be no down side to this deal for any party. Two weeks of practice turning left and right should be sufficient for a man with his talent to get to grips with an F1 car. What a way for Red Bull to kick off their driver aid program by getting a third Sauber out there.

Tony Manners
Gretna, La.

Robin Miller: Good idea, bad timing. Those days are long gone as Bernie has a set number of cars (22, unless Arrows doesn't pay its engine bill) and no longer can Mario Andretti come in and drive a Ferrari. Doubt if Hornish would have been keen to try without extensive testing but Bryan Herta tested a Minardi recently and was trying to get some funding together but it didn't materialize. Thanks for your comments.




Hasn't Ford been awfully quiet lately? It hasn't announced any sponsorship for the Cosworth turbo program -- but it hasn't said no, either. Similarly, back in May Cosworth ran a much-publicized bench test of the XG normally-aspirated, 3.5-liter motor. With "Ford" branding, this could be an IRL engine. But there hasn't been a word on an IRL XG, either. I would guess that with the current financial crunch (and the money draining World Rally and Jaguar efforts) Ford won't make any new commitments now. But aren't they a good bet for IRL in '04?

Al Gordon
Massachusetts

Robin Miller: I believe next year's series will be titled: The CART FedEx Championship Powered By Ford. Look for the announcement soon. Ford in the IRL by 2004? Very unlikely. The Cosworth program is for 2003 and 2004.




First of all I would like to know what kind of carrying case you use in making the comments you do, keep it up. My question is that if CART's partnership with Ford Cosworth next year, do you think someone like GM will want to jump into CART to combat it's hated rival?

Jonathan Grabowski
Hanover, Mass.

Robin Miller: No, the Cosworth deal is exclusive for 2003 and 2004. See answer above regarding Ford. Not sure what a carrying case is but thanks for watching and reading.




I never thought I would become an IRL fan but after another boring season of CART races, I guess making the switch won't hurt as much. Since I am a Michael Andretti fan first and a CART fan second, the choice was relatively easy. Also, the fact that most of the other drivers I really love(d) to follow including Dario, Helio, Gil, Tony, Max and Juan Pablo are either long gone from CART or are leaving next season, well ... what's the point? My question is although I think Chris Pook has done an admirable job (couldn't they have brought him in a few years ago) what do you think CART's chances of survival are beyond 2003?

Signed, A reluctant new IRL watcher

Michael J. Nolfe
North Kingstown, R.I.

Robin Miller: A lot of people have voiced the same opinion to me lately. CART must figure out a way to bring back the racing that was prevalent from 1995-2000 and one thing that would help is more cars (but that ain't gonna happen next year) and a much better aero package for the short ovals. CART still has many excellent venues but the key is car count. CART needs at least 20 cars and, if they add a few young Americans from their feeder system, it can survive. But next year is the most critical. Pook seems to have a plan for 2005 but keeping everything together that long is a daunting task. Yes, had he been brought in two or three years ago, Honda and Toyota wouldn't be leaving.




How can everybody say the IRL is going in the right direction when nobody goes to the races?

William F. Bizzaro
Rancho Cucamonga, Calif.

Robin Miller: The crowds at Texas are quite good and Kansas City, Chicago and Kentucky were healthy (thanks to the NASCAR ticket package mainly). Phoenix has been a ghost town since CART left it while St. Louis, Homestead and Michigan are puny. Fontana was the worst modern-day crowd I've ever seen. Nashville had a full house but I understand it only holds 22,000.




I keep hearing Sarah Fisher is the most popular IRL driver and I have to ask, How is this determined, and where do I vote? Also, if it wasn't for politics, she wouldn't be anywhere near a F1 car. Keep up the great work.

Dale Robson
Overland Park, Kan.

Robin Miller: The fans vote but it's obvious by listening to the driver introductions at each IRL race or by checking her T-shirt sales or autograph lines that Sarah is the most popular. I think the F1 gig was obviously engineered by Tag-Heuer. Thanks.




With Toyota and Honda bringing its CART teams (and money) to the IRL, thus forcing up the cost of competing on Tony George's "level playing field" while CART is cutting its costs, do you think some of the teams being forced out of the IRL could end up moving to CART? And what happens to the IRL if in 2005 CART comes up with an engine formula Honda and Toyota like better and move their teams back to CART?

Michael Maher
Apple Valley, Calif.

Robin Miller: I talked with several little IRL teams at the Chicago race and they indicated they were looking doubtful for the IRL's higher budget but none of them said anything about CART as an alternative. I know a few IRL teams have made inquiries to Chris Pook but I'm not sure which ones. If Toyota and Honda move on, Tony simply pulls out his checkbook again.




Would it be a smart play by CART to move the Mid-Ohio race to a weekend that does not conflict with he IRL race at the Kentucky Speedway? Especially with big name teams moving to the IRL. Fans in my area that go to the CART race (including myself) may switch to the IRL race because of a shorter drive and closer racing.

Steve Cannon
Cincinnati

Robin Miller: Next year, Mid-Ohio will be Aug. 10 and Kentucky on Aug. 17.




Forget the fact that Michael Andretti doesn't qualify well or win many races these days. He's still the only open-wheel name that rivals those of Gordon and Earnhardt. With that in mind, and putting the loss of the drivers on the track aside, isn't losing Andretti (and to some extent Franchitti) to the IRL a huge blow to CART just from sport-recognition point of view?

Alf Gordon
New York

Robin Miller: Absolutely. Andretti and Al Unser Jr. are by far the most recognizable names, even though their glory days are gone, and Michael was one guy CART could always present to the national media and get respect (and/or print). Dario is also pretty marketable. It's definitely a blow but so is losing those three cars.




With CART drivers and teams jumping ship to the IRL faster than rats off the Titantic, an important consideration has been missed as to why they are jumping -- the awful TV deal CART has. The last race of the IRL season could be seen in every major market without having a cable hook up. CART's last race (I hope not) will be somewhere in the 200s on your cable box. If I have millions I want to spend on supporting a racing team, where do I go? The place that will give me the most exposure for the buck. If CART does fail, it will be because of this awful TV deal.

Lenny Zapala
Schenectady, N.Y.

Robin Miller: Good point. SpeedVision does some neat things but it's only got 50 million homes. I'm sure it hasn't helped CART sell sponsorships although to be fair the IRL still lags way behind CART in sponsors in 2002. When IRL and CART went head-to-head on ABC and CBS, they both draw a 1.0 rating. Very sad, but very indicative of today's apathy toward open wheel.




Now that the IRL has made a huge stride in their quality of racing and teams/drivers do you think the new chassis might have an adverse affect on the racing? If they slow the cars down very much they will lose one of the best things that separate them from NASCAR -- SPEED!

P.S. I wonder if there'll as many complaints from Texas/Chicago season ticket holders about "being forced to buy" IRL tickets next year?

Bill Martin
St Peters, Mo.

Robin Miller: Good observation. One of the things that always set CART apart from everyone else was the fact the cars were fast and tough to drive because of the limited downforce. Unfortunately, it's also made for some pretty boring races the past two years. On the other hand, IRL cars have less power than a sprint car and more downforce than a World of Outlaws sprinter so they're easy to drive compared to champ cars. But their racing is always close because of those rules and the finishes this year were spectacular. Certainly more compelling to watch on TV. But running 220 mph is plenty fast enough and that's what the IRL cars did. It's just restrictor plate racing but fans seems to love it.

As for the NASCAR/IRL ticket packages, I'm sure some people object but if they go to an IRL race it's hard to think they weren't entertained. Especially compared to one of those Cup snoozers at Michigan or Chicago.




More and more, the main stories to be found in NASCAR, CART and F1 circles are those of escalating costs to teams and the demise of the low-budget warriors. Having seen the lack of parity in F1 (the Arrows saga is another mess), the defection of so many CART teams to the IRL, and the widening gap of the have and have-nots in NASCAR, do you think Tony George really was a visionary in the mid-'90s with the creation of the IRL, and do you feel he is actually a savior for open-wheel racing, rather than the destroyer of worlds as is so often reported?

Jason Dinkens
Mexico, Mo.

Robin Miller: No, I don't think Tony George had any vision except he always saw red when it came to CART and his goal was to bury them. They've obviously tried to help in the past three years. CART and Indy-car racing was at an all-time high in terms of competition, sponsors and attendance in '95 and the last thing open wheel needed was another series. The month of May and open wheel have been severely damaged by the split and I'd call Tony George a lot of things but savior wouldn't be one of them. If you don't think there's going to be a widening gap next year in the IRL, just wait.




Wow, I can't believe it. I remember in July or August of '01, I got home early on a Wednesday, sat down and watched RPM. Robin Miller made the wild claim that Penske would switch to Toyota and Dodge. I almost died laughing. Now, it's all coming true. Sorry for doubting you, Robin.



Pasha Nosrat
San Diego, Calif.

Robin Miller: Good memory but I have to credit A.J. Foyt. He told me that in August of 2001 and I reported it the next day. Now I hear he's going to have Toyotas next year. What irony. Thanks for watching.




It seems that you usually have a pretty good sense of what is going to happen in the racing world before it does. Take Andretti/Green Racing; you said they were going to the IRL many months ago. I'm sure you heard rumblings about Ganassi's crews being told they were going to the IRL. My question is, with all your accuracy, not to mention your relative lack of secrecy, why does anybody tell you anything, if you are only going to publish what is supposed to remain secret? I know, in the roller coaster enthusiast world at least, that if anybody on the inside of major news leaks the info, they will lose their sources. Why do your sources keep talking? I thank them (and you) for continuing!

Jonathan Davis
Park Ridge, Ill.

Robin Miller: The great thing about motorsports is that there are no secrets. Mechanics, drivers, owners, PR people -- everybody likes to talk about the secret stuff and deals. I've been around for 33 years as a reporter and I should be able to find things out -- with a little help from my friends.




I saw in an article you wrote for CART.com that Patrick Carpentier was being pursued by two IRL teams before he resigned with Player's. Which IRL teams were courting the Canadian?

Ryan Sheets
Bloomington, Ind.

Robin Miller: One was Michael Andretti's and I know Pat talked to Morris Nunn also.




I really enjoy your columns,especially the "mailbox" ones. I do have a problem with your anti-IRL, pro-CART stance most of the time. Why is it that you always seem to fault the IRL, while praising CART? I know that Tony George started the IRL to supposedly give American drivers a chance and to control cost, but should he just sit back and ignore the fact that CART is just doing everything it can to sink itself? You constantly praise Chris Pook and he just keeps going on the same track. CART is losing teams and all I hear is that "Everything is OK." Do people really invest their money in this operation? I know that Tony George may be a hypocrite, but wouldn't it be worse if he ignored this chance? Thanks for saying what you think.

Roger Mercer
Katy, Texas

Robin Miller: I openly criticized Tony George for starting the IRL because it damaged Indy and open wheel racing in general. There was nothing wrong with Indy-car racing in '95 -- great crowds, competition, plenty of sponsors and TV ratings that weren't all that far off NASCAR's. Now, both series are struggling for survival and NASCAR just keeps pulling away. But while I was critical of TG, I covered the IRL races and wrote positive features on IRL drivers and teams just like always but people never remember that. Bottom line, I have a lot of passion for open wheel and it kills me to see it dying. I hope it can be rescued sometime in the next five to 10 years and return to one, strong series but I don't hold out much hope. As for Pook, I give him credit when it's deserved and rail on him when it's deserved. But he inherited a pretty sad situation didn't he? Thanks for writing.




How would Formula One drivers do in Winston Cup and what kind of road and track racing have the fastest overall cars?

Will Beauchamp Jr.
Sacramento, Calif.

Robin Miller: I'm sure with the right team and testing program, an F1 driver could get competitive in NASCAR. Better yet, how about Jimmy Spencer running a McLaren at Spa? I'd pay to see it. At Montreal this year, the CART cars were six to seven seconds slower than F1 on the same track. But a few years ago, before the F1 tire war, the times were very similar. CART cars ran 240 mph on an oval (Fontana) and have the fastest straight line speeds but an F1 car is lighter, more nimble and therefore quicker on a road course. Unless it would be the old Spa or Monza circuits, then CART cars might rule.




With the 2003 CART schedule out, what are the chances that they will come back to Houston in 2003 or 2004?

Brian Donk
Austin, Texas

Robin Miller: There is talk CART might return to Houston in 2004.




With Andretti leaving CART for good, will CART try to field any other U.S. drivers for the 2003 season? A one-man show (presumably Jimmy Vasser) seems like it would be hard to sell to a U.S.-based TV media. Does this mean that we would see a flux of novice Atlantic drivers trying to wrestle 800 HP?

Bill King
Summerville, S.C.

Robin Miller: If CART has any sense left, it will make sure at least three or four guys like Buddy Rice, Alex Gurney, Rocky Moran Jr., Jon Fogarty, Ryan Hunter-Reay and Joe Hand get a ride next year or there may not be any Americans in the series.




Now that Andretti is going to the IRL with all the other CART teams do you think that Tony George will decide to go to more then INDY and Watkins Glen as you predict? It would be the smart thing to make the IRL more diverse.

Phil Cardinale
Allentown, Pa.

Robin Miller: I think Sears Point will be included and Indy may only be for the Infiniti Pro Series.




I have never liked your opinions on racing, or most of anything else for that matter (what a way to say hello, huh?). Reading you in the Star for as long as I was able led me to that opinion. But I would like to commend you on the fact that when you report factually on racing you seem to put aside your feelings and report fairly, and I and other IRL people appreciate that. I do; however, want to take issue with something I have heard and seen you say time and again. And that is that open wheel should get back to where it was with the fans, and you always point to 1995 as that year. I think that open wheel racing was in a downward spiral well before that (I believe you say that year because that was the year before the IRL officially started). I think you could more accurately point to 1992 as the previous high point in open wheel. I have to stop on that subject or I'll go forever, but I think you know the circumstances of that season and the one immediately preceding.

Now, two factual questions. First, will the IRL ever incorporate the word INDYCAR into it's name? I know there were copyright issues, and I thought the name went back to Tony George already or will soon. Also, do you think with more teams and more reliable equipment (i.e., Honda, Toyota and the possibly unnamed Nissan engine), that they will expand the races to 400 miles and a few 500 milers?

Whew, that was a long one for my first question to you, hope I didn't wear you out. One final thought, I may not agree with your opinions, but I like to read/watch them, so keep up the good work.

DJ Odom
Anderson, Ind.

Robin Miller: Thanks for your passion and honesty. In 1995, CART had its largest crowds ever at Phoenix, Milwaukee and Michigan, the TV ratings averaged 2.5 and weren't too far behind NASCAR and the competition was intense and getting deeper. Seven years later, we've got a Civil War with no winners except Bill France Jr. I always championed the little guy at Indy and if Tony George would have started the IRL in 1990 (like I once suggested to him), Indy-car racing might be King right now. I've badmouthed CART more than any other journalist in the past 25 years and praised it when deserved. I've dared to try and tell the truth about what was going on. But we all know that May has been reduced to a one-day event and open wheel racing is upside down. Indy car was actually leased to CART at one time but it belongs to Tony George again and I think you may see the Triple Crown reinstated (500-milers at Fontana, Michigan and Indy).

Send this story to a friend | Most sent stories
 

Related
Robin Miller answers user mail, Aug. 28

Robin Miller answers user mail, July 30

Robin Miller answers user mail, June 4

Robin Miller answers user mail, May 23

Robin Miller answers user mail, April 17

Robin Miller answers user mail, April 2

Robin Miller answers user mail, March 7

Robin Miller answers user mail, Feb. 24

Robin Miller answers user mail, Jan. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 8

Robin Miller answers user mail, Dec. 2

Robin Miller answers user mail, Nov. 15

Robin Miller answers user mail: Nov. 12

Robin Miller answers user mail: Oct. 11

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 26

Robin Miller answers user mail: Sept. 10

RPM user comment central

Sports Mall

 
ESPN.com: Help | PR Media Kit | Sales Media Kit | Contact Us | Tools | Jobs at ESPN.com | Supplier Information | Copyright ©2007 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information/Your California Privacy Rights are applicable to this site.