| ESPN Network: ESPN.com | RPM | NBA.com | NHL.com | ESPNdeportes | ABCSports | FANTASY | |
![]() | |
|
| |
|
Thursday, October 11 Updated: November 12, 2:27 PM ET Robin Miller answers user mail ESPN.com Check out what questions RPM.ESPN.com users had for Robin Miller -- and Robin's answers.
If CART and IRL cant get make one series I think they should be kicked out of the Indy 500 and let F1 race the 500 instead. You would have the Schumachers, Montoya, Villeneuve all on the same track. I miss you and Benner at the Indy Star. B.J. Johnson Indianapolis Robin Miller: B.J.: There's plenty enough talent in CART and the IRL to make Indy as good as it should be and I think Jacques and Juan are the only two F1 drivers who would go for your suggestion. I know it's a mess, but maybe some day it will all be back together. Thanks for your note, Bill and I both miss writing for The Star.
The recent engine specs announced by CART for 2003 has many teams scratching their heads, one owner looking to take legal action and maybe two long time engine suppliers claiming they will leave the series. How many current CART teams do you feel may run a full IRL team and schedule next year and not just one or two "practice" races to gear up for a run in the 2002 Indianapolis 500? Will sponsors dictate the decision? David Miltenberger Marshall, Mich. Robin Miller: David: Yes, sponsors will dictate, but I think Penske is a definite possibility to jump to the IRL in 2002 with Marlboro, while Ganassi will go there in 2003. Will both remain a presence in CART? Depends on sponsors, but I hear Penske is done with CART, I'll see if he'll confess to that this weekend at Laguna Seca. But there will be at least six or seven CART teams at Indy in 2002, the way it looks today. While a normally aspirated engine formula is not bad, CART has clearly moved to the Toyota/IRL camp and my not survive as a series. Honda is clearly gone, do you think Ford wants the Indy 500 bad enough to stay with CART? John Sietsema Earlville, Ill. Robin Miller: JOHN: I think Ford is out of open wheel for at least 2003 but I assume a lot depends on all the lawsuits with Explorer, etc. Honda might also return in 2004, that would be a plus because they do so much else off the track for CART. One thing for sure -- it's a mess, isn't it?
The IRL race at Texas Motor Speedway had cars running at speeds equal to the practice speeds that caused problems leading to cancellation of the CART race there. Has any plausible explanation been given for IRL's ability to do this when CART cannot? Bill Webb Lafayette, Calif. Robin Miller: Bill: No, the IRL didn't come close to running the speeds CART practiced or qualified at. There were laps in excess of 230-238 mph by CART, the IRL was some 15-20 mph slower.
Didn't Tony George say something eerily close to what Joe Heitzler says here?: "CART's leadership position in open-wheel racing dictated for us to make an aggressive step toward the future in the best interest of our sport," CART chairman and CEO Joe Heitzler said. "We will have a normally aspirated formula similar to all major racing series in the world, including Formula One, but will continue to have our own distinctive engine formula for the most competitive and challenging series in the world."
TG said it in late '95? Everyone said TG was an idiot and they were yelling for his head. "He's wreckin' open wheel racin'" the lynch mob said. Who's the visionary? Nearly every major media outlet sided with CART. They jumped all over TG at every opportunity. Probably because all the sponsor perks and freebies they get from them, they hated to see that end. Now the free catered stuff they load up on is crow, hope they like it -- a la CART. See ya at Indy --'02.
Robin Miller: Shawn: I'll certainly agree the CART owners are starting to make Tony George look like a genius, but let's not forget that instead of trying to create an orderly, professional change of attitude, he used the 25/8 hammer and not only divided open wheel racing, but severely damaged the status of the Indy 500. He did cause major damage to open wheel racing and it's reflected in the TV ratings and oval-track attendance. But, alas, CART wasn't smart enough to take advantage of the opportunity to rule. See ya in Indy.
Since it appears Honda and Ford are gone after 2002 and Toyota has yet to commit to CART, could this be the end of CART, literally? If so, what happens to the huge pool of driving talent in CART since the IRL consists of low-budget teams? Scott Sutton Tipp City, Ohio Robin Miller: Scott: If CART doesn't get some engine support, quickly, the 2003 season would seem to be in a bit of a bind, although I suppose they could find some sort of spec engine as a band aid. Trust me, based on what we've seen at Indy the past two Mays, the IRL doesn't want to see CART's teams all come to the IRL. And CART's format of four disciplines of racing remains the toughest test in the world, it just doesn't seem to have a plan does it?
It's well known drivers go through more than one helmet a year. Does the driver provide it or the team? What does the helmet of a well dress CART/IRL cost ready to wear? Howard Rosten Mankato, Minn. Robin Miller: Howard: Some drivers in F1, CART, IRL have helmet deals while everyone else simply receives free ones from Bell, Simpson, Shoney, Ari, etc. A helmet like Schuey or Andretti wears would cost you $350 to $400.
Two things: I think the best show at IMS is qualifying for the F1 race. There seems to be a higher level of intensity and excitement, almost as good as bump day, pre-IRL. After attending the first two years of qualifying, it seems the attendance has gone up and is larger than the first day of qualifying for the 500. Does it seem the same to you? Also, why can't CART use both turbo and non-turbo engines? I know there's problems with that, but I do remember the 500 field from '68 and there was all sorts of different configurations. Thanks ESPN for giving Robin a forum. Joe Callahan Franklin, Ind. Robin Miller: Joe: Let's face it, qualifying is THE SHOW for most F1 races, aside from whatever brilliance Montoya can provide with over-taking. I do think there were more people at F1 quals than IRL 500 pole day, absolutely, both years. If the track just had a couple of challenging corners it would be great because I like F1. Yes, there were all types of different engines during the old days at Indy but it's just not feasible anymore -- especially in this economy. Glad ESPN has given me a forum.
I've always enjoyed reading and listening to you and am happy that you have a column here at ESPN. (BTW, what's up w/On Track, and where can I read Jonathan Ingram? Anyway, my question is what will CART, my favorite series despite its 'shoot itself in the foot' approach to doing business this year, look like after 2002? Will there even still be a CART w/o engines or an Andretti. So let me know five good reasons why CART will survive and thrive in the coming years. Stephen Miller Closter, N.J. Robin Miller: Stephen: OnTrack shut down it's Web site a few weeks back. Not sure what Ingram is doing just yet, but I saw him at the USGP. Thanks for your support. That's a very good question and a tough one. The best reasons would be the fact it's the best, deepest and most challenging series in this country with some strong fan bases scattered around the world. However, as of this moment it has no committed engine manufacturers for 2003 and beyond and nothing that can be defined as a direction. On the flip side, all the IRL has is the Indy 500 -- it's teams have virtually no sponsorship. Of course that could all change here in the next two years.
Like NASCAR did when they introduced a totally different look when they started the Craftsman Truck Series, what do you think the popularity would be if IRL/USAC created a spec Roadster series -- where the cars would have to be designed like A.J. Watson's '62 chassis (with 21st century metals and safety features -- no cages -- virtual duplicates from '62 with larger tires.) They could be the day before event to accompany the IRL qualifying day plus run a 500K as part of the "slow" second day of qualifying at Indianapolis. - Boz Denny Miller Redondo Beach, Calif. Robin Miller: Boz: Quit smoking that California reefer, son, the roadster era is over. We can't bring back Parnelli, Herk and Branson. If the IRL can muster up enough cars, I guess it wants a series to train its future IRL drivers. But Toyota Atlantic (with a little more horsepower) would seem the better alternative, in terms of competition. Nice to hear from you, take care.
Per your Oct. 7 column, I found it interesting that Marlboro was making such an issue of a race at Nazareth, Pa. I have attended that race the last five years and it was nowhere close to being full. Moreover, it's short tri-oval layout makes it nearly impossible to pass. Do you think an IRL race can be either a financial or artistic success? Also, where were all the Philip Morris folks? If it was so important to them, they could have paid for some advertising. There were no ads in the N.Y. or Philly papers, and not even a billboard on the highway. Paul Monticciolo Andover, Ma. Robin Miller: Paul: Good points, although I know the Marlboro folks always had a large group at Nazareth. Remember, before the split, Nazareth had full grandstands so maybe it's the Indy 500 aspect and maybe the IRL will fill the place up. There are a lot of good racing fans in Pennsylvania. As for promotion, yes, that's where the billboards need to be -- not two miles from the track.
First I'd like to thank you for your "no holds barred" approach to reporting. It's VERY refreshing in a sport in which drivers and reporters spend too much time trying to please sponsors and sanctioning bodies. I only wish you would dig your teeth into NASCAR as well. I'd also like to ask a question. I'm admittedly not as well educated about open-wheel racing as I am about stock-car racing. With CART's upcoming engine changes, will (if possible) CART/IRL expand their starting grids to support interleague racing while not leaving the "regulars" hung out to dry? Even though the IRL races at Texas have incredible finishes, they would be even better if 30 cars were running when the checkered flag fell. Thanks for your time. Jason Emley Saratoga Springs, N.Y. Robin Miller: Jason: Our hope is that maybe the Triple Crown (Indy, Michigan and Fontana) could be rejuvenated and both series would participate. The IRL has 15 races for 2002 and CART at least 22 (and both have contracts that go well into this decade with those tracks) so how can they run together anywhere else? Not sure it's feasible. But those three 500-milers would surely be a good draw and Michigan needs something to revitalize it. Obviously, CART has much more depth than the IRL and it's very obvious in the races. As for NASCAR, that's a despicable group isn't it? Mike Helton is still thinking about making the HANS or some safety devices mandatory?! Pathetic. Thanks for your kind words.
What is the story with Reynard and Lola? Are they going to make both IRL and Champ Car chassis? Bill Wagenbrenner Columbus, Ohio Robin Miller: Bill: That's my understanding.
1. What do you think of a special day where F1 drivers could get into a IRL car (probably safer than a Champ or F1 car) and take a few laps around the REAL Indianapolis Speedway, the oval? 2. What do think of an CART race on the F1 circuit at Indy? I bet it would sell. 3. What do you think of a NASCAR race on the F1 circuit at Indy? Nothing could be more boring that Stock Cars on the oval circuit. Larry Shield Burnt Chimney, Virginia Robin Miller: Larry: CART cars and IRL cars are both safer than F1 but, other than Montoya and Villeneuve, you won't have many takers about running the oval. I'm sure most would like to take a few laps at a reduced pace but those two are the only ones who would want to race on the oval. I think there are almost too many races at Indy nowadays and another one with CART on the road course would not sell. I do like your NASCAR suggestion, but I'm not sure the fans would. Like you said, it couldn't be any more boring than the Brickyard 400.
How about this for the IRL/ISC marriage! We received our renewal for next year's schedule at Michigan. ISC charged us $95 for great, center grandstand seats for the CART race this year. For the same seat for next year's IRL race ... $40! If they would have charged $40 for the CART guys, maybe the place wouldn't have been half empty. Any clue on how the tickets can be soooo much cheaper? Also, who do you think is going to end up in the second Ganassi seat, and why? (Memo gets my vote!) Karyn Stiller Pittsburgh, Pa. Robin Miller: Karyn: Thanks for that information, very interesting but certainly not surprising. ISC didn't want that race to succeed and we all said the same thing -- lower the prices. Gee, maybe they have a partner in Tony George. Memo and Bruno are both out, Ganassi is trying to buy Kanaan from Morris Nunn. I think Memo and Bruno have both proven they're good racers, but Chip is so spoiled by Montoya and Zanardi that he has no patience. And no clue about these two. Sure, Bruno has made some dumb mistakes, but he's a rookie. Hell, Memo almost won Cleveland, runs strong at Michigan and Chicago and gets third at Houston and didn't join the team until the seventh race. If you hit the lottery, maybe you can help him get a good ride for 2002. He's exactly what CART needs -- a positive story. Thanks.
What exactly do you not like about the IRL's engine/chassis specs? How are these current specs detrimental to a racing series that wishes to be the premier open-wheel series in the US? How would you want to change these specs and how would these changes make the IRL a better racing series? In short, I'm interested to know what the IRL would have to do (re: specs) to get your full approval. Marc Kepler Los Angeles Robin Miller: Marc: In my mind, Indy cars/champ cars are supposed to be the most challenging and fastest cars to drive, at least in this country. The IRL cars, with rev limiters and those big World of Outlaw wings, can be driven by anyone from a clueless dentist to the son of a rich kid with virtually no experience (can you say Ricky Treadway?). The turbo engine sounds and performs like a real race engine should but maybe it's run it's course and none of the manufacturers (besides Honda) seem to care if it goes away. But you can still make some serious horsepower with a normally-aspirated engine and I would hope that's what CART will do -- provided it has an engine manufacturer by 2003. To make the IRL a thoroughbred, get rid of the rev limiter and those massive wings and then we'll see who can handle it. But if the last Indy 500 was any indication, the IRL teams don't want to see CART coming to their playground -- en masse. My approval means nothing, it's the race fan that needs to be sold on open wheel racing -- and corporate America. I just want to see all the best drivers and teams at Indy and in one series. Thanks.
Why is Toyota so important to CART? They only make a decision on the engine formula after Toyota makes an ultimatum. Wouldn't it make more sense to try and satisfy or keep a couple of engine manufacturers instead of just doing what Toyota wants? In the end, the last manufacturer to enter CART is the one who calls the shots. Keep up your way of covering this series, so maybe the all important members of the board at CART would listen to you one day. With all this "good news" my sentiments really are with the shareholders of CART. Ivan Roman Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic Robin Miller: Ivan: I'm not sure who CART is trying to satisfy but I think maybe the owners panicked when they found out Penske and Ganassi are going to the IRL in 2002 and 2003 and that Toyota would at least still be competing. But to make a knee-jerk decision and dust off Honda is bad business. Ford may be out regardless so this all adds up to a major mess. How can such a kick-(butt) series be run so poorly, say my friends in the F1 media. Thanks.
A two-part question: Would tire heaters like the ones used in F1 have lessened the chance of Zanardi's crash in Germany? Why does cart not use the gear selector on the steering wheel like F1 this would be one less reason to take the driver's hands off the wheel? John Stewart Marquette, Mich. Robin Miller: John: No, Alex's tires were already warm (he didn't change them on that stop, just took on a splash of fuel). He was just hurrying to get back into action and lost it -- the tires or steering wheel had no bearing.
Come on Robin, you're smart enough to figure this out. Toyota wasn't playing CART like a violin; they are both on the same page. Run Honda and Ford out of the series so when CART folds and becomes part of IRL they have some cover when the legal wars start with their shareholders. Joan Gannon Marengo, Ill. Robin Miller: Joan: Naw, that would mean CART was thinking ahead and that never happens.
I would like to know who might be going to new teams in the IRL next year? Kenny Micheff Robin Miller: Kenny: Panos and Penske?!
I am an avid CART fan, and I am very concerned with the decisions that have been made of late. Dropping Homestead, Nazareth, and Michigan are disasters. The fans on the East Coast have no races to attend. We are virtually ignored. The engine choice just gives Tony George more to chortle about. CART offers the best and most varied racing bar none, and yet they constantly make decisions that hurt their image. What can we, avid fans, do to help CART make changes that will benefit them and us? On a personal note, I don't always like what you have to say, but I respect and admire your honesty. You always "call 'em as you see 'em". Can you make a dent as far as getting those three tracks back on the schedule? Cheryl Schwartz Byram, N.J. Robin Miller: Cheryl: I do feel sorry for CART's fans because they have to be as confused as they are concerned. Remember ISC and Tony George are partners and that's why those three tracks went to the IRL (plus, Homestead and Nazareth faded in attendance and promotion). Losing Michigan was the big disaster since CART has staged four the greatest races of all-time there the past four years. But, again, did CART leave or were they simply shown the door? I don't know who to believe. I guess you could write CART a letter or send a petition. Thanks for your passion. Keep the faith.
Why didn't CART adopt F1 engine specs? Would their be more engine manufacturers interested in CART, if they did? Maybe bring a couple back to CART (Benz). Or would the snub-nosed F1 prevent any such nonsense? Both series are international, unlike IRL. Open-wheel racing is not just turning left. I'll watch NASCAR for oval racing. Nothing against the IRL, just reminds me of the old World Football League. Rick Ishida Bothell, Wash. Robin Miller: Rick: That sounds like a great option, but it makes way too much sense.
How many drivers have to be killed before the powers that control stock car racing realize there cars are dangerous? Will someone step up and pull there heads out of the sand long enough to show them they are playing Russian roulette with the stars and future stars of the sport. Maybe you can start some kind of dialogue with NASCAR and convince them that maybe they should do something -- now. Larry Smalligan Fremont, Mich. Robin Miller: Larry: I wrote a couple of stinging stories about NASCAR'S lack of safety when I was still at The Star, but it did nothing. No full-time medical people, no full-time safety team and nobody looking out for the drivers. It's criminal.
As a long time CART fanatic it pains me to see them struggling so much. The heart of this problem is that the racing isn't as good anymore. Wouldn't it make sense to go down to a V-6 turbo configuration and give them their old wing package back? Pouya Tavallodi San Bernardino, Calif. Robin Miller: Pouya: Some tracks like Laguna and Houston need to go away and be replaced by Watkins Glen because CART's cars clearly have out-grown them. The wing package for the mile tracks has been a joke the past few years and ruined even Milwaukee but the German race was excellent in terms of passing and racing so that wing package looks good.
I know you have a disdain for the IRL, however, I do enjoy and support the series and was excited about the announcement that they will race at Michigan and now Fontana next season. My question to you is, now that they have added these two big former Penske tracks, (now ISC owned & operated), I have never read or heard of any talk about racing at Pocono. I remember the Indy cars always putting on a pretty good show there. Is there talk of an IRL event at Pocono? If not, why? I do enjoy your work and commentary, even though I don't share your view on the Indy Racing League and Tony George. Bucky Butler Coconut Creek, Fla. Robin Miller: Bucky: I don't disdain the IRL people, I disdain what the IRL concept did to my beloved Indy 500. And open wheel racing around this country. Anyway, Pocono is simply too rough for Indy cars and that's why CART left. Thanks for your note.
I heard a rumor at Mid-Ohio about Tony Kanaan going to Ganassi. Any truth to it? Tyler Wells Newark, Ohio Robin Miller: Tyler: Chip is trying to get his contract from Morris Nunn but nothing official, yet.
I really enjoy your insight on open wheel racing. Could you give us your predictions on silly season ... specifically Target, Rahal, PacWest and Mo Nunn Racing? Richard Ventura Yorba Linda, Calif. Robin Miller: Richard: Rahal will be Vasser and either Buddy Rice or Alex Barron; PacWest says it will be back with Big Mo and Dixon, although everyone in the paddock wants Dixon; Target will be Brack and Kanaan if Ganassi has his way, but Morris Nunn will not simply give Tony K. to Chip. Morris could be Kanaan and Hoover Orsi or Casey Mears or maybe Bruno Junquiera. Stay tuned and thanks for reading and watching.
Thanks for getting ESPN.com to give you place to answer our questions again -- I missed not reading up each week since the Star column. Two questions - Heinz-Harald Frentzen claims he has been contacted by at least one CART team for a drive next year. Any guess who that is and what the odds are of him coming to the states? And what about Johnny Herbert? He has maintained that he is interested in CART as long as he had a chance at Indy as well. Also, Paul Tracy really hasn't had such a good year after losing Tony Cicale as his engineer. I also wonder if the addition of Andretti has hurt him either on his own doing (mentally) or through less resources/focus. Do you think there is still a chance of him moving to another team as early as next season or will TKG/Motorola stay just as they are for sure? Jason Hill Sterling Heights, Mich. Robin Miller: Jason: Herbert said the same thing last year but, to my knowledge, nobody contacted Herbert -- he just announced he was coming to CART. Haven't heard anybody talking up HHF as yet. As for Tracy, hard to tell what makes him tick. Despite his talent, PT is very fragile emotionally and Cicale was very good for him. I thought he might go to Player's but that isn't going to happen. He'll stay with TKG.
How exactly does the tobacco settlement work out for open wheel racing? I notice that Marlboro seems to be getting the short end of the stick, not being able to put Marlboro on anything, where Kool is able to put their logos on posters and other promotionals. Hollywood, I noticed is in CART and the IRL, and Marlboro was only allowed to be in CART during the Indy 500 ... What's the whole story here? Ryan DuBrall Eagan, Minn. Robin Miller: Ryan: No, the tobacco legislation effects everyone equally. A brand can pick out one series to advertise in and that's why it's either CART or the IRL here or CART or F1 in Germany and England (KOOL and Marlboro could not advertise). Marlboro started out advertising at Indy but pulled its signage before the race when someone complained to the Attorney General's office.
You hear this all the time but I am going to say it again because I really mean it. You really are great. You're honest, straight forward and very informed and I really appreciate it. Now, here's my question. If all the present CART drivers were in identical cars, with identical budgets, leaving only "set up" as the intangible, Who would win the series points race? Steve Shanahan Moline, Ill. Robin Miller: Steve: Not sure that question can be answered. Helio and Brack seem to be the fastest drivers, week in and week out, and they're both in the hunt for the title. De Ferran is very consistent while guys like Carpentier, Kanaan and Dixon don't seem to be far away from having breakthroughs. Franchitti is hot and cold, but still very talented and capable. Thanks for your support.
A friend and I are going to be at Laguna Seca next weekend for the race. We really are hoping to get a chance to meet you. Are you easily found in the paddock on race weekends? Brad Stevens Lodi, Calif. Robin Miller: Brad: I'll be walking around all weekend with my RPM2Night hat and sweatshirt. Look me up. |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
ESPN.com: Help | PR Media Kit | Sales Media Kit |
Contact Us | Tools | Jobs at ESPN.com | Supplier Information | Copyright ©2007 ESPN Internet Ventures. Terms of Use and Privacy Policy and Safety Information/Your California Privacy Rights are applicable to this site. |