ESPN

25 years of controversial decisions

Grid
4 of 11
Previous
Next

James Toney-Dave Tiberi

Photograph By Holly Stein/Allsport/Getty Images

Feb. 8, 1992: James Toney took on lightly regarded Dave Tiberi in Atlantic City and, from the looks of it, was soundly beaten. Not according to two of the scorecards in the split ruling, which were so egregious that they prompted a senate investigation.