Matthew Berry

  (3:05 PM)

'Sup kids... let's get to it. As always... all subject answered

Gifford Ocean NJ

I am in my superbowl. You say not to get cute especially if you dominated all year, like in my case. Do I still start Pierre Thomas over Ladainian Tomlinson?

Matthew Berry

  (3:06 PM)

I would. TB has not given up a rush TD at home all year. Pierre has DET, is hottest RB in the league right now and has no Reggie. That's not getting cute. That's playing the match-ups

Mitchell (fargo)

Andre Johnson the 25th ranked receiver for this week? Please explain.

Matthew Berry

  (3:08 PM)

Basically it's because of Nnmadi... And the whole every other week thing for Kevin Walter... I expect big games from Slaton, Walter and Daniels... and have Andre as a top 3 play... just think he won't go off the way he did last week. That said - it's your team. Start him if you want

Jim (Tampa, Florida)

Where do you rate A. Gonzalez now that Harrison doesn't start? Better than Driver? Housh? And Rhodes over Sammy Morris if Addai doesn't start? I'm not starting Barber & need help! At least I got the Burner starting

Matthew Berry

  (3:09 PM)

I have Ag around 35 w/out Harrison. I'd start Driver over him and yes on Rhodes if Addai is out

Fantasy Virgin (NJ)

I actually made it to my championship. Do i dare start Rhodes over LT?

Matthew Berry

  (3:10 PM)

If Addai is out... you could risk it. It's close... I'd probably go Rhodes, yeah.

Mr. Fredo (Who care)

Tough question for a league that counts return yards. Ryan Grant or Leon Washington.

Matthew Berry

  (3:10 PM)

Leon

Ben (Charlotte)

I haven't been in your chats in a while. Are you still funny? And do you still have a man-crush on Yovani Gallardo?

Matthew Berry

  (3:11 PM)

Yeah, I noticed that too. I think it's mostly because I chat on Thusdau now and now Tuesday. Thursdays folks are more serious, gotta get line-ups in, etc etc... I get Waaaaayyyy fewer "funny" questions or comments. Yes on YoGa.

Danny (Indy)

Peyton Manning or Kurt Warner? "short weeks favor the offense" still?

Matthew Berry

  (3:12 PM)

yep. Read my rankings but yes, short weeks favor the offense. Esp. the Colts. MJD is only Jag I trust tho

Ric (Kansas)

How can you rank Andre Johnson so low after he just ripped a good passing defense for 200+yards? He also seems to get 7-10 catches on most occassions. You also rank Tony Gonzalez(probably the most reliable TE in fantasy over the last 2 months) at #13. So you're telling us that if we are in a 10 to 12 team league, most in our championship game, WE SHOULD NOT START TONY G!? You are freaking nuts my friend! You probably won't post this because you'll realize that you're an idiot and go change your rankings. I think being in that ESPN Verizon (might be Sprint) commercial is making you forget how you became famous in the first place.....GIVING SOUND FANTASY FOOTBALL ADVICE!!! Now stop trying to be Simmons, Gallo is here for that.

Matthew Berry

  (3:14 PM)

That was a typo. I had Gonzo at 3 originally because Miami plays TE so well but then I looked at who I would rank above him and I didn't like it so I chnaged it to one. But the 3 didn't get erased. it's been fixed on the site now but that's why - my stupid fingers. It was chnaged well before your post Ric. Besides, I already know I am an idiot.

Jason Jersey City, NJ

WHY DON'T I EVER GET MY QUESTION ANSWERED?? Advent reader for several years of your column, Mr. Roto you are a god to me, please help me!! I'm in the championship of a deep ppr league and lost Marvin Harrison for tonights game, my choices are Avery, Gage, Northcutt, or deep sleeper on waiver i.e. Jason Avant...Please what do I do to make sure I muster at least 5-10 pts. I'm leaning towards Northcutt...

Matthew Berry

  (3:15 PM)

Can you put in a good word for me with Ric from Kansas? Go Northcutt and pray

Joe (NYC)

Will Cutler play the whole game if Denver clinches? I have Thiggy on my bench I am not sure what to do.

Matthew Berry

  (3:17 PM)

Did you seriously just ask me to predict what Mike Shanahan will do? It's a very legit concern because by the time the Denver game happens it could not mean anything for them... If I had a viable option like Thigpen, I'd play Thiggy

Craig (PA)

Isnt this "fantasy sports chat", not just football, so can i get a basketball question? Should i deal TJ Ford and Thad Young for Rondo?

Matthew Berry

  (3:18 PM)

Hard to answer w/out knowing rest of your team... With Brand out a month Thad's value goes higher... it's not a terrible deal but it depends on if you have the depth. If eithe guy would be on your bench, do it. If you are starting both Thad and TJ, hold off

Brian (pittsburgh)

If Gore doesn't play - Foster or Portis?

Matthew Berry

  (3:18 PM)

Portis

Kevin (DC)

I'm leaning towards starting Schaub over Romo, but does the Nnamdi factor make this a bad play?

Matthew Berry

  (3:19 PM)

No... still love Schaub... Walter, Daniels, Slaton....

Token Gay in Championship (Chicago)

'Sup handsome. Looking for a little validation. Play Dunn flex for sure thing numbers vs. Deion Branch, or Chester Taylor.

Matthew Berry

  (3:20 PM)

Well thanks, sailor. I like Branch and Taylor over Dunn actually.

Yoda ( Cosmos)

Warner have a lights out game this week, will, or play a half and sit the rest, hmm? Herh herh herh.

Matthew Berry

  (3:21 PM)

I'm a little worried about Warner this week. That's a concern, so is weather, Boldin is banged up, they are on road vs a team that needs a win, they got shut down last week.... My guess is Warner is fine and puts up solid numbers but I just have a weird gut feeling that something isn't 100% right...

Ben (Charlotte)

Do you have a girlfriend yet? I'm telling you, the line, "The balder the Berry, the sweeter the juice" would be gold for you.

Matthew Berry

  (3:23 PM)

I will DEFINITELY try that... hilarious

Joe (Chicago)

Well, this is it. 2K on the line. Believe it or not, I value your advice, but it's only a portion of my decision making. For my flex, would you go with Rhodes tonight, or wait till Sunday and go safe with L. Moore or (gulp) D. Foster if he starts? This all assumes that Addai plays, cause if he doesn't, it's an easy decision.

Matthew Berry

  (3:24 PM)

Still go with Rhodes with Moore (now w/out Reggie) a close seocnd. I think Gore plays

Steiny (NYC)

Why didn't Jeff Fisher let Rob Bironas try that 49-yard field goal?

Matthew Berry

  (3:25 PM)

in his post game press conf Fisher said "We thought about it, but I knew it would screw Steiny from NY."

Playing the gorilla

I need Flex help; R. Brown, B. Edwards, or K. Walter.

Matthew Berry

  (3:26 PM)

Brown assuming it's Ronnie. By the way, I'm not answering start sit questions unless they are flex... that's what my rankings are for

Chris - Boston

MB - those speed typing classes are not paying off for you - loads of typos !! Put down the Bud Light and use 2 hands. Portis, Lewis, Ward, or Rhodes - need 2.

Matthew Berry

  (3:27 PM)

Dude, you want quick answers and me to get as many as I can or you want perfect grammar? There's over 3000 questions in here

Big Loser (Chicago, IL)

Rather than make a drunken move, I just came right out and told my friend I really liked her. She told me "thanks". I also started Reggie Bush over Pierre Thomas last week... which do you think worked out worse for me?

Matthew Berry

  (3:28 PM)

Bush over Pierre. You can always get drunk and make anohter bad move. But Pierre's game is lost forever

John, nyc

Is Steven Jackson's "lightheadedness" a worry to you? I feel like he's in for a big Sunday if he's "100%" (100%, when referring to SJax, has gotta be in quotes...)

Matthew Berry

  (3:28 PM)

no, not that worried

Andrew (Everett Wa)

Could all of you corner Karabell and tell him that weather is a factor. He rips everyone in his chat's that mentions weather.

Matthew Berry

  (3:29 PM)

Well, I agree that it is but also agree with Eric in the sense that people tend to overrate it sometimes... you'd be amazed at how many huge statistical days came in total snow storms

Rankings!?! Oh, I get it.

Matthew Berry, Will you ever transcend Greatness?

Matthew Berry

  (3:30 PM)

Are you saying I haven't yet?

Nathan, Dallas, TX

You have the Texans DST ranked #1... was that a typo as well or would you really start them over the Eagles?!?!?

Matthew Berry

  (3:31 PM)

No, not a typo. Last three defenses that faced OAK: 11, 15, 14. HOU has at least 8 points in 3 straight...

Justin (Chicago)

How much gloating time is allowed in fantasy? a week after and then during next years draft? fully until the following draft? up to the first game of next year?

Matthew Berry

  (3:31 PM)

Until you die.

Tim (Latrobe, PA)

Loyal podcast listener here. Love it. Rankings don't help with this one: I have DRhodes AND Gore AND Foster. If Addai is OUT tonight....do I roll with Rhodes? Or play whoever starts for SF vs. the hideous Rams? Problem with that is, both SF RBs might play and split the carries. Ugh.

Matthew Berry

  (3:32 PM)

if Addai is out, yes, go with Rhodes. If Addai plays, go with Gore.

Sam (Brisbane, Australia)

Why do you think colston goes off but moore stays quiet? antonio bryant a more reliable play than either?

Matthew Berry

  (3:34 PM)

i don't. I have both ranked fairly high. I do like bryant quite a bit... probably over moore

BJ (Cincy OH)

I rode the Chris Johnson train all year, but since he's playing the steelers am I crazy to start Cedric Benson over him?

Matthew Berry

  (3:36 PM)

not crazy... I understand it. I probably would still go with CJ but I understand the temptaion and wouldn't have a problem if you did

Sam again (Brisbane)

Marques colston 3, lance moore 29... or else you're having a shocking week for typos

Matthew Berry

  (3:39 PM)

No, I like Moore - I did the ranks before the news that Bush was out... I'll upgrade him some... but yeah... I like him less than Colston

John (Los Angeles)

Based on your sources, do you believe Nnamdi will be following Andre Johnson all over the field? Based on the games I've watched, he generally just stays on his side of the field and defends the guy that comes his way. Could be a big mistake pushing Andre down so much if he is only getting Nnamdi 50% of the time (or less).

Matthew Berry

  (3:43 PM)

Yeah, it's been off and on. Sometimes he's all over the #1 guy, sometimes he's on one side of the field. My thinking is that after seeing what Randy did to them last week and seeing Andre's game last week they spend more time on Andre. But you're absolutely right. Look, rankings are often a guy call on some level... that's what my guts says here. Plus Andre hadn't done a ton for the weeks leading up to last...

Andy (Phoenix)

More fun name to pronounce: Nnamdi Asomugha or Adewale Ogunleye

Matthew Berry

  (3:44 PM)

Neither, man. I'm on TV trying not to look moronic to begin with. Last thing I need are names like that. Gimme Kevin Smith every day of the week.

IRATE!!!!!

DAMN YOU BERRY! I DEMAND YOU EXPLAIN HOW YOU CAN RANK A.JOHNSON SO LOW. AND DON'T GIVE ME THAT HE PLAYING THE RAIDERS. HE JUST TORCHED THE TITANS #3 RANKED PASS D.

Matthew Berry

  (3:44 PM)

scroll down

Charles Carstens Sabbathia (NY)

Matthew, is that you? It says Tristan on the link Running back debacle! Starting Slaton and Pierre...knowing injuries/fueds with coaches...who do I use at flex: Portis, Gore, Foster, Ricky, or Lance Moore

Matthew Berry

  (3:45 PM)

yes, 'tis me. Go Portis.

Dan (DC)

If Addai is out, is Rhodes a better play over Portis?

Matthew Berry

  (3:45 PM)

No. Portis runs well against PHI traditionally.

Jer (DC)

Having an awkward moment of flexual tension.....Cotchery or Rhodes?

Matthew Berry

  (3:45 PM)

Rhodes. Great line

Jim (NYC)

Man up to your AJ pick.... Stay far far away from either MBIII and Choice this week?

Matthew Berry

  (3:46 PM)

Actually, I think Choice will be ok. He's been good vs PIT and NYG

Ryan ( Miami, Fl )

Just watched ur video........."Thats a hot little biscuit!"....lmao!

Matthew Berry

  (3:46 PM)

Thanks

John (NJ)

I know that the Browns are playing Cinn, but to be ranked #1? Should I drop Indy's or Miami's defense to Clev instead?

Matthew Berry

  (3:47 PM)

I would play INDY's tonight

John (LA)

After losing my semi-final contest by 2 FPs this past week when westbrook failed me, I've got a new found respect for the work of fantasy writers. It was literally, and pathetically, one of the worst days of my year, and I can't imagine how stressed you guys must be when your teams/gut calls go awry. Keep up the good work!

Matthew Berry

  (3:47 PM)

thanks. But seriously, at the end of the day, I've got a pretty sweet gig. Don't feel sorry for me.

Tshimanga Biakabutuka (Panthers)

Tshimanga Biakabutuka

Matthew Berry

  (3:48 PM)

LOL

DA

Portis against the Eagles without Jansen or Samuels over Foster against the helpless to stop anybody Rams? Can you please elaborate? I know Portis is a stud, but he's a stud with a 2nd team O-line and facing a good, motivated run defense. (This is all assuming that Gore is declared out prior to gametime)

Matthew Berry

  (3:49 PM)

I know. But I think Zorn is coaching to save his job here and what if you lose? You're gonna look back and go... what was I thnking? I benched Clinton Portis for DeShaun Foster.....Evn with the jansen and samuels injuries I expect a solid game from Portis

PJ Athens, OH

Just an FYI for Andre J - last 7 weeks - TD in 4 of 7 - over 100 one of the other games andd the other 2 were vs. IND and BAL. Ave of 12 points with a low of 5. Also - do appreciate everything just have an unnatural man crush on AJ so I must defend.

Matthew Berry

  (3:55 PM)

Here's Andre's last 5 games on road: at GB 4/55/TD ; at CLE: 10/116/ 0 TD ; at IND 4/55 ; at MIN 4/62/TD ; at JAX 3/38. He's actually scored in 3 straight games. But didn't have a TD in the three games prior to that. He had over 100 yards only once in 6 games. An avg of 12 points is solid but not spectacular.... Dude, start him if you want. I like him - I just don't love him this week. That's all.

Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice...

Despite going with your Redskins recommendation last week, I survived and am in the championship. Do I dare pick up and play Houston instead of my Dolphins D?

Matthew Berry

  (3:55 PM)

A little worried about a shoot-out in KC... I do like the HOU D, yes

Tim (MD)

Flex Nightmare...cant decide: Driver, Bruce, Holt, or Mo Morris?

Matthew Berry

  (3:56 PM)

Bruce

Jeff ND

WR...T Gonzalez or D Bess??

Matthew Berry

  (3:56 PM)

Tony G

Chris (NJ)

Mr. Dropsy Michigan or Chris Johnson at the flex?

Matthew Berry

  (3:57 PM)

I say CJ. He'll have trouble running vs. PIT but i can see him being a big factor in pass game

Mike (Indy)

I was told by the Answer guys to start Rhodes this week over Grant even if Addai is playing. Do you agree with that? Also does the injury to Boldin concern you at all? Play him or Wayne. Both are for my Flex of course. Thanks!

Matthew Berry

  (3:57 PM)

yes and go Wayne

Ken (CA)

Anthony G. or Dallas Clark?

Matthew Berry

  (3:57 PM)

Clark

Matthew Berry

  (3:59 PM)

ok gang. Gotta run. Thanks for stopping by - good luck this week!