12Ty Cobb 1911

.420/.467/.621, 8 HR, 127 RBI, 11.4 WAR

Pick your poison -- Cobb had four seasons with 11.0 WAR. In 1911, he set career bests in RBIs and runs (147), leading AL in both. Also led in steals (83), hits, doubles, triples and OPS. Named MVP.

21Rickey Henderson 1990

.325/.439/.577, 28 HR, 61 RBI, 10.0 WAR

Cecil Fielder nearly won MVP honors even though Rickey led AL in OPS as a leadoff hitter. Scored a league-best 119 runs in 136 games, swiped 65 bases and hit 20 of his 28 HRs on the road. Deserved a Gold Glove.

Share your vote:
Tweet your vote:

  • Ruth 1921

    Wilson 1930

  • DiMaggio 1941

    Pujols 2003

  • Yastrzemski 1967

    Sosa 2001

  • Wagner 1908

    Speaker 1912

  • Cobb 1911

    Henderson 1990

  • Morgan 1975

    Schmidt 1980

  • Hornsby 1922

    Robinson 1949

  • Mantle 1956

    Piazza 1997

  • Bonds 2001

    Bench 1972

  • Rodriguez 2000

    Griffey Jr. 1997

  • Musial 1948

    Brett 1980

  • Mays 1962

    Banks 1959

  • Yount 1982

    Aaron 1957

  • Gehrig 1927

    Collins 1913

  • Ripken 1991

    Foxx 1932

  • Williams 1941

    Carew 1977

sweetspot2012:matchup=7645433+ty cobb 1911+vs+rickey henderson 1990