Updated: May 4, 2005, 1:25 PM

Vote: Is Derek Jeter's defense overrated?

You've seen who ESPN MLB Insiders Steve Phillips and Gary Gillette think are baseball's underrated and overrated players, but what's your take? Which players seem to get more credit than they deserve, and which players never seem to earn the acclaim their play merits?

Is Derek Jeter really that good with the glove? Is Orlando Cabrera better? And does Mark Buehrle get overlooked when discussing pitching aces?

And while you're at it, which managers are coasting on reputation and which are earning extra wins for their team? And which stadiums get more love than they deserve? Help us correct conventional wisdom, SportsNation.


You must be signed in to post a comment

Already have an account?