Johan Santana used to be a yearly contender for the Cy Young Award, but he's been shut down after allowing at least six runs in each of his past five starts. Is Santana done as one of baseball's best pitchers?

• Vicious023: "That no hitter was historic but people will always question the impact it had on his health."
• CHRONIC16: "Santana's career was shut down the day he came to the Mets, like so many."
• sixfeettall23: "It's a shame to see Santana's rebound season completely unravel over his last five starts. What a dominant pitcher he was in his Minnesota years. Not the only former Twins pitcher to be mishandled, see Liriano, Francisco."
• yandz: "Santana really looked like he was heading for the Hall of Fame while with the Twins . Doesn't look like thats going to happen anymore."
• Cleveland State Vikings 3.0: "Why do people act like throwing 134 pitches is why he is having troubles? ever think maybe he is in a massive funk because he tries to throw a no hitter every time? People act like he threw 200 pitches. The dude is a professional athlete, I think throwing 20 more pitches than normal in a game isnt going to make or break his arm."

Join the conversation or respond by signing in or creating a profile and blogging.