We'd never fault a player for going all-out in the playoffs, but Matt Holliday might have crossed a line in taking out Marco Scutaro in Monday night's loss to the Giants. Scutaro had to leave the game as a result of Holliday's hard slide, which Giants manager Bruce Bochy called "illegal." You can see video of the slide above -- was it simply a hard play that saved an out, or something more?

Which team wins Game 3?

The Giants weren't deterred by Holliday's hard play -- they took care of the Cardinals rather handily.


Which team will win Game 3 of the Cardinals-Giants NL Championship Series?


Discuss (Total votes: 103,107)

Comment »