Rank 'Em: All-Time Home Run Derby

Created: July 10, 2009, 1:24 PM

Where would Willie Mays finish?

Josh Hamilton might have put things together too late in his career to make a run at Cooperstown, but the slugger put on a show for the ages in last year's Home Run Derby. But what if the best home run hitters of all time could take the field in their prime for the ultimate slugging derby?

From iconic figures like Babe Ruth and Hank Aaron to fallen stars like Mark McGwire, this isn't about ethics or popularity; it's about hitting the ball over the fence. Would Babe Ruth have the endurance? Would Roger Maris put on a show like his 1961 season? Rank the field in their order of finish.


 
How are the points calculated?
On a poll with 10 options, a No.1 ranking equals 10 points, a No.2 ranking equals 9 points, etc. The item with the most points will be ranked first.
 

  • Hank Aaron

  • Barry Bonds

  • Reggie Jackson

  • Mickey Mantle

  • Roger Maris

  • Willie Mays

  • Mark McGwire

  • Frank Robinson

  • Babe Ruth

  • Ted Williams