Rank 'Em: NFL Quarterbacks
Created: November 2, 2009, 8:10 AM
Where does Aaron Rodgers rank?
Who are the best and worst starting quarterbacks in the NFL?
Brett Favre got the best of Aaron Rodgers for the second time this season in a Week 8 showdown at Lambeau Field, but Rodgers still boasts the league's best quarterback rating. Eli Manning and the Giants suddenly can't win, while Tony Romo's Cowboys and Donovan McNabb's Eagles can do no wrong. We even have a Vince Young sighting. It's clearly time to rank NFL quarterbacks again.
Size up the league's collection of starters, and help us put them in their places, SportsNation.
-
Rank 'Em: NFL Quarterbacks
-
(#1 Votes)Points
-
1
Peyton Manning
(341)
23,809
-
2
Drew Brees
(207)
23,219
-
3
Brett Favre
(134)
22,098
-
4
Tom Brady
(44)
21,383
-
5
Ben Roethlisberger
(18)
18,370
-
6
Aaron Rodgers
(17)
16,097
-
7
Donovan McNabb
(8)
15,869
-
8
Carson Palmer
(3)
15,522
-
9
Eli Manning
(1)
14,988
-
10
Philip Rivers
(5)
14,820
-
11
Joe Flacco
(2)
14,253
-
12
Matt Ryan
(1)
14,232
-
13
Tony Romo
(6)
14,178
-
14
Kurt Warner
(5)
12,997
-
15
Jay Cutler
(1)
12,377
-
16
Kyle Orton
(0)
12,065
-
17
Matt Schaub
(2)
11,940
-
18
Matt Hasselbeck
(0)
9,372
-
19
Mark Sanchez
(1)
8,241
-
20
Matt Cassel
(0)
7,657
-
21
Chad Henne
(0)
7,111
-
22
David Garrard
(0)
6,939
-
23
Alex Smith
(2)
6,498
-
24
Jake Delhomme
(0)
5,814
-
25
Matthew Stafford
(0)
5,765
-
26
Trent Edwards
(0)
5,513
-
27
Vince Young
(1)
5,414
-
28
Marc Bulger
(0)
5,229
-
29
Jason Campbell
(0)
4,434
-
30
Josh Freeman
(0)
3,480
-
31
Derek Anderson
(4)
3,474
-
32
JaMarcus Russell
(1)
2,156
YOUR RANKINGS
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.
- 7.
- 8.
- 9.
- 10.
- 11.
- 12.
- 13.
- 14.
- 15.
- 16.
- 17.
- 18.
- 19.
- 20.
- 21.
- 22.
- 23.
- 24.
- 25.
- 26.
- 27.
- 28.
- 29.
- 30.
- 31.
- 32.
-
1
Peyton Manning
- Total SportsNation Votes: 804
How are the points calculated?
On a poll with 10 options, a No.1 ranking equals 10 points, a No.2 ranking equals 9 points, etc. The item with the most points will be ranked first.